Can a Cute Vintage Nickname Revive a Dusty Old Lady Name?
By Linda Rosenkrantz
Like our cousins across the pond, we’ve fallen in love with vintage nicknames for our girls—names like Maisie and Mabel and Sadie and Josie and Hattie are already on the rise. But do those parents who want a little Hattie necessarily consider putting Harriet or Henrietta on the birth certificate?
Maybe, maybe not.
In some cases, the adorable short form is actually succeeding in waking up its sleeping mother name. Like Josephine, for instance, and Beatrice. But here are some others whose full versions have not seen as much—if any– action, as adorable as their period nicknames may be.
Which of these cute, often tomboyish, girl nicknames do you think are capable of reviving their more staid Great-Grandma names?
You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.
on February 23rd, 2017 at 6:49 am
Some of those nicknames are worse than the actual name, in my opinion. These names are not my style at all, but Wilhelmina, Lucinda and Keziah are nice without the nicknames.
on February 23rd, 2017 at 7:14 am
I’ve been trying to wear my husband down on Artemisia… so nice to see it on here!
on February 23rd, 2017 at 9:22 am
Oh wow! I NEED a list like this for boys!
on February 23rd, 2017 at 10:08 am
There’s a reason names like Bertha, Ethel, and Gertrude fell out of use–they’re just not pretty.
on February 23rd, 2017 at 10:56 am
All the clunky B names (Brenda, Bernice, etc) and the trying too hard girl variations (Edwina, Ernestine, etc.) are the worst offenders for me.
on February 23rd, 2017 at 11:09 am
@Suzannah – Beauty is in the eye of the beholder. I personally think that the likes of Bertha, Ethel and Gertrude are lovely. And besides, these types of names were popular for dozens, sometimes hundreds of years. They didn’t suddenly stop being used because ‘they’re just not pretty’. There’s more to it than that and, due to their lack of use prompted (presumably) by a multitude of cultural, societal and fashion-based reasons, they now appear ugly to most of us 21st century folks because we’re not used to hearing those sorts of names anymore. But that’s just my opinion…
on February 23rd, 2017 at 12:51 pm
@Aldabellax– This is an opinion site, My opinion is that many names on this list are harsh sounding. To me, they don’t “appear ugly”, they are ugly. Of course, whether or not someone likes a name is completely subjective. I had an Aunt Ethel, an Aunt Wilma and an Aunt Muriel–all names I would never name my daughters. There’s no reason to politicize something as individual as liking or disliking a name.
on February 23rd, 2017 at 2:13 pm
Vintage nicknames are my thing! I love Aggie, Dot, Bea, Frankie, Gertie (prefer Trudy though) Lottie, Lulu, Minty, Romy, Tillie, Winnie, Zetty.
Jake for a girl though, crosses the line for me. Shouldn’t some boys names be off limits?
on February 23rd, 2017 at 2:27 pm
I’ve got a bit of an on/off thing with nicknames, but I adore vintage ones. It’s definitely the tomboyish, feisty feel and image they have, and they just add some spice and energy to some heavier names. My personal favourites are Sybil nn Sybbie, and Beatrix nn Trixie, and from the list:
Effie for Euphemia
Evvie for Evadne
Hettie but for Henrietta
Liddy for Lydia
Lula and Lulu but for Tallulah
Minnie for Minerva (but I’m planning to name a cat this one day)
I think Lolly or Molly would also be cute for Olympia
Tavy for Octavia
Tilda for Matilda
Tommy for Thomasina
Zetta for Rosetta
Roberta nn Bobby (I started to really like Roberta because of Roberta nn Bobby in The Railway Children)
Edith nn Edie
Georgiana (or Georgia/Georgina) nn Georgie
And just as names I like Alberta, Roberta, Desdemona, Eudora, Essie, Florence, Frankie, and Antoinette.
on February 23rd, 2017 at 2:33 pm
I have been falling in love with older name as I get older, they are just timeless, beautiful and have something about them that is so appealing. Harriette is so sweet. I adore Tilda, by itself and as a full name 🙂 Dot is so cute for Dorothy, Frankie for Francine or Frances is adorable, Lulu for a Louisa is darling, so many cute nickname options for older names.
I also think Gia or Gigi would be great nicknames for Eugenia. Ellie or Elle or even Ella I think would be great and a modern twist for Helen or Helena and Hero/Hera or Mira/Mia are cute for Hermione.
on February 23rd, 2017 at 2:35 pm
Ooh, and Matilda nn Mattie! For some reason I quite like/don’t mind boyish nicknames for girls (depending on the name) even though I’m not usually a fan of boys’ names on girls.
on February 23rd, 2017 at 8:35 pm
Esther, Lucinda, Lavinia, Matilda, Rosetta, Eleanor, Keziah, Eulalia, Jemima and Flora are the best on this list!
on February 23rd, 2017 at 9:28 pm
I think Kezzie for Keziah and Zaza for Tirzah are most likely to revive the old lady name…though I don’t really see either of these as “old lady” names.
on February 23rd, 2017 at 11:15 pm
My most-likely-to-revive list (in no particular order):
Aggie/Agnes or Agatha
Frankie (although I feel very conflicted here because I also like this for a boy as a nn for Franklin)
on February 24th, 2017 at 5:57 am
@Suzannah: Culture and fashion and politics do shape our subjective opinions (which you are obviously entitled to) of names. I agree with you on Ethel, but Gertrude (which I used to think horrible) has grown on me. When I was a kid, I thought the two ugliest names in the world were my grandmothers’ – Edith and Edna. Fastforward 25 years and I love Edith and gave it to my daughter as a middle name.
I thought Edna would be a harder one to warm up to, but I heard it on a 6 year old at the doctor and thought… hey, that actually is kind of cute. Even more amazingly, my mother agreed!
This is not because the name was once ugly and is now improving. It’s to do with the nostalgia (the grandmother’s are dead, I want to remember them) and the changing of the naming landscape, with names like Elsa gaining in popularity.
on February 24th, 2017 at 6:43 pm
I’m so happy to see Theodosia on here! It’s my favorite name. Some of these names aren’t my style, but I don’t hate any of them. Very good list!
on February 24th, 2017 at 11:15 pm
I’m tired of people accusing other people of “politicizing” names. Everything is political or cultural at some level or other.
But! This list is fabulous!
I too would love to see the male version as well.
I love almost all of these long names, but am not much interested in the nicknames.
on February 24th, 2017 at 11:47 pm
Ethel is just about the softest sounding name there is… it’s practically Elle. Not harsh at all unless you’re trying to make it sound bolder than it is by saying it loudly. It’s a quiet, unassuming name.
I would hesitate to use any of nicknames that are becoming popular for boys. I also wouldn’t bother with nicknames for many of them, like Harriet and Ethel, or biblical ones like Esther, Beulah, Lydia and Keziah.
Aggie for Agatha
Hettie for Henriette
Lally for Eulalia
Nellie for Helen
Vinnie for Lavinia is too cute… but I think Vince and Vincent are becoming more popular for boys these days
on February 25th, 2017 at 8:57 am
Cool list! Yes, as others have said, some of these names are still “dusty” (read: unattractive), but this could be a great way to honor a family member. And vintage names are so trendy right now that a lot of these really wouldn’t seem too anachronous.
ETTIE—Harriet (or really anything with an -ette ending)
on February 25th, 2017 at 10:35 am
I love Billie, but as a nickname for Sybil.
on February 26th, 2017 at 2:49 pm
I dislike most of these names & there’s nothing political about it…I’m of the age where they sound old-fashioned & clunky to me. My paternal grandmother was named after her two grandmothers & thus was Nellie Augusta, & hated both her names; my maternal grandmother (through the decree of some nuns; long story there) ended up being Mathilde & hates her name as well.
Of the names on the list that I like, I prefer the full versions for more of them (Bethia, Virginia, Jemima, Carlotta, Lucinda, Eleanor, Octavia, & Theodosia) than the nns (the only nns I’d use would be Ginger & Tavy). If I were to use nns for the others, I’d probably go w/Thia, Jem, Carly, Cinda, Nell, & Thea, but the longer versions are much more attractive to my ear.
on March 2nd, 2017 at 11:59 am
I adore so many of these names, this is totally my style!
on March 4th, 2017 at 6:39 am
I’m liking Tillie, Tilda, Ethel and Thea
leave a reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.