We made waves recently by writing a piece for The Daily Beast about Hipster Names. Almost universally, the cry went up: Oh no! I’ve given my baby a hipster name! “I have a one-year-old named Matilda,” one mom wrote. “I hate you.”
Ooops, sorry. We love the name Matilda. Really! We’re just a little confused about why hipster has become such a dirty word.
Or not. I mean, we do get it, in a way. There’s something sneering, something dismissive about branding someone or something “hipster.” It connotes the feeling that someone (or something) is trying too hard to be cool, which of course is the definition of uncool.
Would not caring about style lead you to transcendentally cool names? Or thoroughly uncool ones?
Insert deep sigh here.
The real question on many parents’ minds: How do you choose a name that’s genuinely stylish and interesting but that’s neither too hipsterish or too uncool?
Let’s play (and for you Message Board fans, this would make a great Name Game):
Too cool: EVA
Too cool: LENNON
When it comes to calling the sweet spot, we’re not always that sure of ourselves either — or in agreement. (After I posted this, Linda emailed me, Estelle? Really???) We’d love to hear your ideas on which names hit the sweet spot, and why.