Girls’ Names in Limbo: When can Kay come out to play?

Girls’ Names in Limbo: When can Kay come out to play?

We’ve all pretty much on board with the Hundred Year Rule that says it usually takes a full century for a name to shake off its musty image and start to sound fresh again. Which is why so many turn-of-the-last-century names have returned, names we don’t associate with any older person we have actually known–those belonging to the great-great or great-great-great grand generation–all those lacy girls’ names like Amelia and Matilda and Clementine that now sound so appealing.

But what about the girls’ names of the generations that followed those in the first half of the twentieth century? Most of them are much more simple and matter of fact, often two syllables rather than three or four, feminine rather than feminissima.  These would be the names of our grandmothers and great-aunts and mothers-in-law—the older women in our lives.

Though there are some exceptions, such as the relatively recently revived Sylvias, Audreys, Lillians and Evelyns, and starbabies like Julia RobertsHazel and Sarah Jessica Parker’s Marion—most of these examples that were mega-popular from the twenties to the sixties have been consigned to onomastic limbo.

Our question today is: Are any of them ready to be sprung?

Listed here some of the names that were most popular back  in their day—leaving out the classics, the nicknames and the ephemeral trendies.  They’re in reverse chronological order, starting with the names that peaked in the 1920s, showing the time span in which they ranked in the Top 100, followed by the highest number they ever reached.

And who knows? Maybe we’ll come up with a Half-Hundred Year Rule!

1920s

Bernice 1900-36          #39 in 1921

Doris 1902-54                #6   in 1929

Gloria 1922-63              #29 in 1925-26

June 1915-49                 #39 in 1925

Lois–1902-1953              #17 in 1929-30

Lorraine1918-48        #39 in 1928

Marian1912-34           #64 in 1924

Marjorie1904-45        # 16 in 1921-23

Maxine1915-30           #76  in  1923

Phyllis–1916-58            #24 in 1929

Virginia1893-1959    #6 in 1921

Wilma1912-40           #62 in 1925

1930s

Arlene 1931-43             #53 in 1934

Barbara  1913-76          #2  from 1937 to 1944

Beverly 1926-64           #14 in 1937

Dolores 1923-44           #13 in 1930

Elaine 1923-57              #42 in 1938

Geraldine 1916-46       #38 in 1931

Janet 1928-70                #17 in 1939

Jeanette 1936-41          #82 in 1939

Joan 1924-64                  #5 from 1931 to 1933

Joanne  1930-60           #45 in 1934-35

Joyce 1924-89               #11 in 1937-38

Loretta 1931-44             #62 in 1938

Marilyn 1925-58           #13 in 1936-37

Marlene 1931-42           #39 in 1935-36

Norma 1918-47             #22 in 1931-1932

Rita 1914-60                    #42 in 1930

Roberta 1935-53           #64 in 1936

Shirley 1918-63              #2 in 1935-36

Wanda 1922-66             #47 in 1934

Yvonne  1935-37         #77 in 1937

1940s

Bonnie 1928-66               #33 in 1941, 46, 50

Carol 1928-71                 #4 in 1941

Ellen 1880-1961 (on and off)  #59 in 1942

Glenda 1941-52               #79 in 1944

Judith 1934-64              #4 in 1940

Kathleen 1920-90        #9 in 1949

Kay 1936-45                      #70 in 1941

Linda 1936-77               #1 from 1947 to 1952

Rosemary 1926-49      #75 in 1946

Sandra 1934-94              #5 in 1947

Sharon 1935-77             #8 in 1943

Suzanne 1941-73           #52 in 1946

1950s

Cynthia 1945-93            #7 in 1957

Deborah 1950-76          #2 in 1955

Denise 1950-81               #23  in 1955-56

Diane 1937-71                 #14 in 1955

Donna 1926-76                #5 in 1959-60

Gail 1937-61                      #36 in 1951

Janice 1932-67                 #21 in 1951

Marsha 1946-54              #68 in 1950

Nancy 1920-78                 #6 in 1950

Pamela 1943-83              #10 in 1953

Paula 1943-74                 #38 in 1954

Susan 1937-85                #2 1957– 1960

Valerie 1953-87             #60 in 1959

60s

Anita 1937-67                 #77 in 1963

Annette 1957-67           #62 in 1960

Brenda 1939-77             #11 in 1961

Karen 1938-85                #2 in 1965

Lisa                                       #1 1962-69

Michelle 1954-2007    #2 in 1968-69, 71-72

Renee 1960-78                #62 in 1967

Teresa  1938-81 #18 in 1961- 63

So which if any of these names do you think show some promise of returning?  Would you use any of them yourself—and not just because they’re family names?

About the Author

Linda Rosenkrantz

Linda Rosenkrantz

Linda Rosenkrantz is the co-founder of Nameberry, and co-author with Pamela Redmond of the ten baby naming books acknowledged to have revolutionized American baby naming. You can follow her personally at InstagramTwitter and Facebook. She is also the author of the highly acclaimed New York Review Books Classics novel Talk and a number of other books.