Baby Names Quandary: Use it now or bank a name you love?

Pick Felix now or Felicity later?

posted by: sanctanomina View all posts by this author

By Katherine Morna Towne @ sanctanomina

I did a name consultation not too long ago for a couple who had picked out Felicity for a girl, which was a name full of meaning for them, only to discover they were having a boy, and they couldn’t think of any boy names they loved as much as they loved Felicity.

When I posted the dilemma to my blog, one of my readers suggested Felix to them, reasoning, “Since [the mom] was really excited about Felicity’s meaning and saintly pedigree, Felix really seems the perfect alternative to me! Popular in the UK, Spain, and Germany, it definitely has a hip, continental thing about it while not being unusual or hard to pronounce, and the x-ending makes it flow very well into middle names beginning with either a vowel or a consonant!”

Several other readers thought Felix was the perfect idea as well, and one of them shared, “We did this with our first. We loved Natalia for a girl, but he was a boy. Naming him Nathaniel kind of nixes a future Natalia.”

I’ve come across this question of whether or not to reserve names for future use several times, in one form or another. I see it in cases like the one above, where the male variant of a beloved female name might be the perfect option for this baby, but for the fact that parents might not want to let go of the girl name “just in case.” Or when parents love two names for the same gender (Anna and Catherine) and can’t decide between them, and wonder if they should use one as the first name and one as a middle (Anna Catherine)—thus potentially setting them up for having a first child with both their favorite names and an unsatisfying list for the next child of the same gender.

So what guidelines might be good to consider when faced with a “this now or that later” dilemma? Two rose to the surface in the comments by my readers that I thought were really great:

Name this baby as if it were your last

Several people pointed out that nothing is a guarantee—whether because of advancing age, or struggles with fertility, or having all of one gender, or even just life circumstances taking away the possibility of adding to your family, you can’t be sure that this baby, here and now, won’t be your last (or your last of this gender). One reader said, “I do NOT save names. Based on my fertility history, I NEVER assume there’ll be another baby.” Another pointed out, “I’ll be nearly 40 when this baby girl is born. I don’t have nearly the number of favorites I had when I was younger and certainly less impulse to save as I know this could be our last … all-out-naming is the way to go.” Naming each baby as though there were no more coming down the line might help you feel more peaceful about the name you choose.

Which name would you be sadder to not use?

Interestingly, this question can work in opposite ways. On the one hand, contemplating, “Which of the names I’m struggling with would I be sadder to never have the opportunity to use?” can clarify for you that naming a son after your dad really is more important to you than using your objectively favorite name. On the other hand, you might realize that you’d be devastated to lose out on naming a potential future daughter Felicity by naming your actual son Felix now—you’d rather take the chance of never having a daughter than naming a son Felix and having a daughter later and not being able to use Felicity. As the mom of Nathaniel-not-Natalia put it, “If [Felix] hits all the right notes, great. If Felicity still makes their heart sing and Felix is just okay, then I say save Felicity.”

I personally started my motherhood on the save-for-later end of the spectrum, and have moved closer to the use-the-best-name-now end the more children I’ve had. Our youngest boy has a variant of my mother-in-law’s first name as his first name, thus knocking out of contention the ideas we’d had for honoring my mother-in-law with a daughter’s name. In making that decision it helped that we would have put her name in the middle name spot for a girl, not the first name spot, and that my husband and I truly love our youngest boy’s name. But if there was a male variant for our first-name pick for a girl (there isn’t), my sense is that I would still want to save our girl name, even knowing we might not get to use it. It’s definitely a hard decision!

Have you encountered this dilemma in your own naming? If so, how and what did you decide?

Subscribe to our newsletter

* indicates required
sanctanomina Berry Juice default profile image

About the author


Kate is a writer, lifelong lover of names, wife to a really good man, and mama to their six boys ages 2 to 11. She shares her thoughts on Catholic baby naming at Sancta Nomina.
View all of sanctanomina's articles View all Berry Juice Bloggers


3 Responses to “Baby Names Quandary: Use it now or bank a name you love?”

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.

Penguinkin Says:

May 3rd, 2016 at 3:06 pm

Definitely name as if each was your last baby. Personally I feel that each child should have a meaningful story behind their name, but if it is just as simple as ‘we loved your name so much that we couldn’t name you anything else’ then you should be using a name that you completely love. I have a HUGE list of criteria for names but I know that whatever we use next will be decided purely on that child rather than any future potential babies.
Imagine the conversation in the future, ”we really loved X so we named you Y in case we had X in the future’ sub text- bet YOU feel special and loved!

gmdx Says:

March 8th, 2017 at 11:37 pm

I’m a long way from having children but I do feel this. Girls names are much easier for me to love, so I have a longer Girls list full of names I like more than any on my Boys list with gender variants on either side. Hypothetically speaking, I think it’s worth it to give up the possibility of Mary for March or Marius even though I like Mary more, because I’ll still have Eliza and Beatrice for the next child.

Baby Name Remorse: Helping Your Children Love Their Names – Baby Name Blog – Nameberry Says:

March 12th, 2017 at 10:45 pm

[…] It can be stressful too, yes, and we’ve all heard stories of name regret and read strategies to help avoid it, or manage it and move on, or start afresh by changing the name, but in every aspect of this […]

leave a reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.