Jemima, the name of a strong and beautiful Biblical daughter of Job, has long been among the chicest choices of aristocratic Brits, most recently ranking at #231 there in 2017. But despite its lovely sound and peaceful meaning, this attractive name hasn't ranked in the US Top 1000 since 1893, no doubt due to the problematic association with racial stereotyping, exemplified by the Aunt Jemima brand of pancakes.
 Jemima was well used by the Puritans, as was that of her sister, Keziah. Some other famous namesakes are Beatrix Potter's Jemima Puddle-Duck and characters in Chitty, Chitty, Bang Bang, Cats, and Thackeray's Vanity Fair. A real-life bearer is Jemima Kirke, who plays Jessa on Girls--and who happens to have a sister named Domino and a son named Memphis. Jemimah is a variant spelling, as seen in the Antonia Fraser crime series Jemimah Shore Investigates.

Jemima

L'aigle

This vintage name is still used today among the Amish.

Lavina

Leota is an antique name rarely used any more -- it was given to just 8 baby girls in the US in 2021. Some sources says Leota is a Native American name meaning blue flower.

Leota

Lesceline

Liegard

Luitgarde

Maret

Mathilde is even more popular in France than Matilda, a hipster favorite thanks to Michelle Williams and Heath Ledger, is here. And the French pronunciation, while confusing to English speakers, makes it softer and prettier than the version we're more familiar with.

Mathilde

Mechtilde

Maelcorcre

Malatiah

Maloucha

Massy

Morrison

Moss

This is the most popular Welsh form of Agnes.  Variants include Annest and Nest.  There was an eleventh century Nest who was known as 'Helen of Wales' for her beauty and the problems it caused.

Nesta

Nest

Ada, yes.  Ida, maybe.  But Oda, a Scandinavian version of Odelia, not really. To English speakers, it sounds too much like "odor".

Lacks the vintage charm of the original Arabella, but with the love for all names Bella, it might appeal to some.

Orabella

In early, pre-Norman Ireland, this name was borne by both a sister and a niece of high king Brian Boru.  Now, the English form Orla is more commonly used.

Orlaith

Ogive

Osburg

Parvie

Peake

Pernel

Pertonilla

Pietes

NerdyNamer's list "Unusual Female Names From My Genealogy J-P" of 29 great name ideas: Jemima - Pietes!

Unusual Female Names From My Genealogy J-P

Interesting and unusual names from the female side of my family tree from 602-1983. J-P