View Poll Results: Which do you think?

50. You may not vote on this poll
  • Todd Matthew Elias

    6 12.00%
  • Theodore Matthew Elias "Todd"

    44 88.00%
Page 1 of 2 1 2 LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 14
  1. #1
    Join Date
    Mar 2017

    Please help me out...

    I'm looking at honoring my great-grandma Dorothy Ann. I have thought of a combo for a girl, but am unsure how to go about doing this for a boy as I want to honor a Todd as well. I've thought about using one of two name combos:

    Todd Matthew Elias
    Theodore Matthew Elias "Todd"

    My great grandma never used a nickname, but to get to Todd I used a common nickname for Dorothy, Dot, and flipped it around (and added a D).

    Which one do you think?

    Last edited by shells15; March 25th, 2020 at 09:51 PM.

  2. #2
    Join Date
    Mar 2020
    I prefer Theodore but I don't think you can get Todd out of Theodore. What about Theodore Todd Elias to keep the honor name?

  3. #3
    Join Date
    Mar 2017
    I looked at it as you would get Ted out of the name... ThEoDore for Ted, TheODore for Tod (I just prefer the Todd spelling over the Tod spelling). Would this not work?

    Last edited by shells15; March 26th, 2020 at 01:25 AM.

  4. #4
    Join Date
    Apr 2010
    I prefer Theodore to Todd in general, so Theodore 'Todd' got my vote. I like too, that Theodore incorporates more directly, the DOR for grandmother Dorothy so the Dorothy honour doesn't get lost in the creative honour, compared to Todd's obvious one, you know?

    I don't see why Todd can't work as nickname for Theodore...I mean, no the names don't relate in terms of etymology or history, however, most people just go on sound and look when it comes to names in general anyway, and the TOD(d) is right there, and in that order. Nicknames are supposed to be fun and informal, so really, they need not even need to make perfect sense anyway, in my opinion.

    Just a quick note to say,
    I'm always up for a chat, so feel free to say 'Hey'!

  5. #5
    Join Date
    Jan 2019
    If I were you I’d use Theodore Todd Elias. I much, much prefer Theodore to Todd and nicknames Theo and Teddy to Todd, and feel Todd is a stretch as a nickname for it anyway. I mean you can of course use whatever name you like as a nickname but I personally like nicknames to be intuitive or established (or both), which Todd isn’t. Plus, considering you say your grandmother never used Dot as a nickname, the connection between Dorothy/Theodore and Todd feels tenuous. It seems to me that the significant Todd in your life would be honoured more so if his name was just used as a middle. If Matthew is important to you as well, I’d go with three middles - Theodore Matthew Todd Elias. It’s a long name but I don’t think that’s a problem. Anyway, just my two cents - feel free to ignore this! I think Theodore (Matthew) Todd Elias is a really nice name though.
    Last edited by tdfm; March 26th, 2020 at 05:33 AM.

  6. #6
    Join Date
    Jun 2013
    Theodore is a wonderful name and has so many sounds and letters in common with Dorothy! It's almost like Dorothy backwards: Dor-oh-thee, thee-oh-dor!!!

    I think Theodore nicknamed Todd makes perfect sense - not a stretch at all! And using Theodore as the given name provides other options such as Theo or Teddy if you feel like using more than one nickname.

    My Top 10 Boys...

    Ephram | Isadore | Phineas | Cedric | Garland
    August | Edmund | Vivian | Casper | Elvin

  7. #7
    Join Date
    Feb 2020
    Todd can definitely be a nickname for Theodore. I think Theodore is perfect for honoring both Dorothy and Todd. Congrats!
    Lila Siobhan • Freya Cedar • Elisa Paige (Elsie) • Coralie Brynn (Cora) • Maia Audrey • Violet Piera • Juliet Iris • Seren Daisy • Lydia Fallon • Genevieve Maren (Eve/Evie) • Hazel Camila

    Roland Leo • Philip Cillian (Finn) • Thomas Royce • Wilder David (Will) • Nolan Judd • Miles Cormac • Jerome Pierce (Jerry) • Shane Lorcan • Hugo Campion (Hugh) • Soren Gregory • Jack March

  8. #8
    Join Date
    Jun 2017
    I know a Dorothy (also called Dorothea) who was named to honour her grandfather Theodore. So you can absolutely tie those two together. I agree, if you can get to Ted, you can get to Todd. To me, both are a bit of a leap and less obvious than Theo, but Ted to me is not more intuitive than Todd. Theodore Todd Elias would work as well.
    Finn, Leo, and Kate <3

    Declan Calder Bartholomew

    Mila Violet Elizaveta

    Elena Daisy Guinevere | Anya Vivienne Persephone | Freya Lydia Juliet
    Aurora Ivy Olivia | Morgana Clara Genevieve
    Isla Belle Sophia | Stella Margot Emmeline

    Oliver Caspian James | Callum Nicholas Evander | August Victor Hugo
    Mason Oscar Theodore | Dimitri Matthew Balthazar
    Theo Frederick Lincoln | Jasper Rupert Anthony

  9. #9
    Join Date
    Feb 2014
    London, England
    Another vote for Theodore Matthew Elias - such a handsome combination! Todd isn't my style as a standalone, but is perfectly fine for a nickname.
    Teenberry | Amateur Photographer and editor | Human to cats Toffee & Fudge

    Adelina Rose ♡ Magdalena Ruby ♡ Edith Matilda ♡ Helena Margot ♡ Ophelia Maeve ♡ Anneliese Charlotte ♡ Sienna Giselle
    Leo Arthur James ☆ Alexander George ☆ Isaac Peregrine ☆ Harry Lysander ☆ Arlo Sebastian ☆ Viggo Florian ☆ Nicholas Ivor

    Crushes: Sierra + Aurora + Delilah + Altair
    GP Crushes: Ximena + Siofra + Olina

  10. #10
    Join Date
    Sep 2013
    South Wales, UK
    Theodore Matthew Elias is wonderful. I also noticed straight away that Theodore is basically Dorothy backwards! And Todd seems a perfectly natural nickname for Theodore. I do think Todd is too nicknamey to stand alone, however.

    I think you've hit a winner with Theodore!
    Sienna Elsie|Eden Olivia|Lyra Isabella|Cora Eloise|Thea Ivy|Lila Iris| Ivy Winter|Lydia Kate

    Ramsey Flynn|Finnegan Reid|Wilder Elliott|Reid Valentine|Flynn Shepherd|Atlas James|Nolan Alexander|Greyson Wilder|Edmund Fox|August Wolf|Sullivan Wyatt

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts