View Poll Results: Rosalie or Rowan?

81. You may not vote on this poll
  • Rosalie

    45 55.56%
  • Rowan

    36 44.44%
Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 ... LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 32
  1. #1
    Join Date
    Jun 2019

    Rowan vs Rosalie

    I'm sorry. I'm sure you're all sick of reading these by now. My IUD comes out in two days and its all becoming actually real that we are going to be trying for a baby that its kind of overwhelming. I want to have things monogrammed so I want a name decided before baby would get here. I'm not one of those "decide when it gets here" types.

    My hubby and I FINALLY have narrowed it down to two girl names... for now. We've been back and forth between these two for some time now, and keep coming back to them, so it's likely going to be one or the other if we have a girl.
    This poll is partially to get public opinion, and also partially because as I see the voting results emerge, I will likely suddenly realize which one I truly want if I'm disappointed/overjoyed that one is winning over the other.

    I love Rowan because it holds so much meaning to my hubby and I. We are both of Scandinavian descent, and our faith is Norse paganism. The Rowan tree is very sacred to Celtic and Norse faiths, and is known as the tree of life and symbolizes courage, protection, and luck. We're both very nature-centered people, also. My therapy is hiking or kayaking. His, too. That is where we bond together and also where we go to find ourselves. I also love the way it flows off the tongue, and the whimsical, gentle sound of it. Rowan makes me think of a bright-eyed, adventurous little girl with bare feet and messy hair. Middle name would either be Elizabeth, after my sister, or Ophelia, after the song by The Lumineers because that band holds so much meaning to my family.

    Rosalie, on the other hand, oh how I love Rosalie. It is so beautiful and elegant, and so underused. It holds so much charm to me, and I love the nicknames that come along with it. That, and I love the meaning behind it. Roses are such beautiful flowers, and it indirectly goes along with my desire to stay nature-themed without being over the top "hippie." Rosalie makes me think of a gentle girl with a bit of sass. I also like how it flows into our last name better, and I think the baby's grandparents would be more approving of it than Rowan. The middle name for Rosalie would be Wilder. My dad and I shared a love for The Little House on the Prairie and we would read the books together and cuddle up in his bed with popcorn and watch the series when I was a child. So Wilder would come from that, Laura Ingalls Wilder. I think part of me is SO torn because I want to use Wilder so badly to honor my Dad, but Wilder does not work with Rowan. At least not for a girl, I don't think.


    Rowan Elizabeth Tucker
    Rowan Ophelia Tucker
    Rosalie Wilder Tucker
    Current favorites:

    Winter AnnaliseRowan ElizabethBeyla NoelleArden ClaireEmelia VioletMirabel JamesRosalie Wilder

    Talon ClaymoreBennett AveryArlo JamesRex MichaelOliver CalvinHenry Alexander

    Step-mommy to Piper Isabella ♥
    Auntie to Octavia Lorraine ♥

  2. #2
    Join Date
    Nov 2018
    I'm really really fond of Rowan Elizabeth!

    Charlotte Isabella | Evelyn Rose | Esther Charlotte | Esther Rose | Evelyn Charlotte

    Benjamin Joseph | Daniel Joseph | Daniel Thomas | Joshua Thomas

  3. #3
    Join Date
    Oct 2016
    Rosalie is one of my favorite girl names—I love the combination of Rosalie Wilder! Based purely on the names themselves, Rosalie would be my pick.

    However, if Rowan holds more meaning for you, go for it! It's bright and fresh. I like Elizabeth of your two middle name options.
    My Lists
    Bird + Birding Baby Names // species names + notable naturalists
    Texas Inspired Baby Names // paying homage to the Lone Star State
    Nautical Baby Names // inspired by sailors + the deep blue sea
    The Golden Age of Detective Fiction // timeless characters + the writers who created them
    Hobbit Baby Names // botanical, medieval + gemstone names from the Shire
    Medieval Names for a Modern Baby // unusual names + surnames from historic rosters

  4. #4
    Join Date
    Nov 2016
    This is so difficult! I love how meaningful Rowan Elizabeth and Rowan Ophelia are but Rosalie Wilder is just so brilliant. I went with Rowan in the end but it was a tough choice
    Sarai Matilda|Una Adele|Ezra Apollo|Sholto Felix
    On the shorter side...
    Mabel Aurora|Lark Imogen|Enid Celeste|Edie Ophelia
    Maeve Saskia|Neve Emily|Carys Olympia|Mabli Corinne
    Wren Felicity|Eve Romilly|Nina Juliet|Lux Emmeline
    Olive Cordelia|Archie Delilah|Polly Evangeline|Flora Scout


  5. #5
    Join Date
    Jul 2018
    Rosalie Wilder is lovely in my opinion!
    not expecting, just a name nerd with a name blog

  6. #6
    Join Date
    Mar 2019
    Rowan Ophelia is lovely. I picked Rowan over Rosalie based on its meaning to you, that sold it to me. I also like the idea of Rowan Rosalie, maybe too cartooney, but kinda cool.

    Little Love

  7. #7
    Join Date
    Oct 2017
    Oh man! I usually do not take too long deciding what to vote for in a poll, but I can't choose! I love both of these two very different very much.

    The combos as well! I think that Rowan Ophelia (I love that song by The Lumineers as well) and Rosalie Wilder are the perfect combination of nature, girly but unisex, and meaningful.

    I think my final answer would be Rowan Ophelia, but you literally cannot go wrong.
    21. Another name nerd not having kids any time soon.

    Rosemary Astoria | Eleanor Lavender | Sylvia Arabella | Thea Winifred | Florence Cecilia | Ophelia Clementine | Beatrice Lucille | Rowena Frances | Hester Juniper | Agatha Primrose | Ginevra Magdalen | Matilda Romilly

    Benjamin Atlas | Theodore Flynn | Jasper Penrose | Elio Rafael | Percival Colin | Gus Leander | Basil Alejandro | Felix Peregrine | Philip Salinger | Emmanuel Birch | Remy Ignatius | Edmund Bastien

  8. #8
    Mommy to twins Arthur Robert and Jasper Steven 💞

    Thinking of: Phoebe Rosalind or Griffin Orlando



  9. #9
    Join Date
    Jun 2019
    Quote Originally Posted by whatchamacallit View Post
    I did actually think about that! I'm not usually a fan of more than one middle name though...
    Do you think Rowan Elizabeth Wilder Tucker is a bit "much?"
    Current favorites:

    Winter AnnaliseRowan ElizabethBeyla NoelleArden ClaireEmelia VioletMirabel JamesRosalie Wilder

    Talon ClaymoreBennett AveryArlo JamesRex MichaelOliver CalvinHenry Alexander

    Step-mommy to Piper Isabella ♥
    Auntie to Octavia Lorraine ♥

  10. #10
    Join Date
    Apr 2017
    Rowan Ophelia is so beautiful! And my preferred between the two Rowan options.
    I voted for Rowan because of that combo. I could've easily voted for Rosalie Wilder!
    If it was between Rowan Elizabeth and Rosalie Wilder I would've voted Rosalie!
    Very close
    Olive Margaret / 21.10.18

    Ginny Florence
    Fay Marigold
    Cecily Fearne
    Eadie Seraphina
    Delphie Claire
    Elma Josephine

    Dustin James
    Grady Theodore
    Willem Cain
    Reggie Maxwell
    Lennox Peter
    Remy Graham

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts