Scarlet, Sylvie or Story?

[nicoleamanda]

Hi berries,

Which of these S names do you prefer and why? Middle name Victoria or Jean. Last name M@cKimmie.

Scarlet
Sylvie
Story

Thanks, x

[theirishsaint]

I kind of like Story Victoria

[greyblue]

All are lovely but i like Sylvie Jean followed by Story Victoria best

[bellerose]

I like Story Jean the best.

[sunniva]

All three are nice, but Sylvie stands out for me. I just love that woodland faerie vibe that I think it exudes. Sylvie Jean makes for a lovely combo.

[yellowplums]

I like Story the most. It's one of those names I can't use but absolutely love and I would be psyched to see it on another child. Story Jean is very sweet.

I like Scarlet and Sylvie too, but I prefer them with Victoria. All good choices.

[jeansea]

The name Story makes me swoon. Love love love it. It is, stylistically, pretty different than Sylvie or Scarlett though. Sylvie would be my second choice. I think both middle names sound great with Story and Sylvie.

[ceryle]

All three are nice, but Sylvie stands out for me. I just love that woodland faerie vibe that I think it exudes. Sylvie Jean makes for a lovely combo.

This exactly.

[babymagic]

While I feel like Sylvie is SO trendy on nameberry, I like it best from this list and don't hear the name very often at all in real life. Most of all I love the meaning. (Sidenote: I think Sylvan would be cool for a girl, even though it's technically a boy's name. And it'd be a great way to get to Sylvie). Sylvie Jean works - Sylvie Victoria less so.

I like Scarlet quite a bit, but don't like the color necessarily.

Story is a bit much for me, even though it has a lot of appeal phonetically.

[kachenka]

They are all lovely stand-alone names but when I take your surname and middle name options into consideration, there is only one that works for me. So my vote goes to Scarlet. I'm not very fond of the repetition of "vi" in Sylvie Victoria, "or" in Story Victoria and the endings of both Sylvie and Story with the "ee" in Jean and M@cKimmie.