Page 1 of 6 1 2 3 ... LastLast
Results 1 to 5 of 29
  1. #1
    Join Date
    Sep 2011
    Location
    UK
    Posts
    1,335

    Do you ever get name disappointment for others?

    I'm wondering if other Berries are ever slightly disappointed by the name announcements from friends and family or their wider social circle?

    For example some friends recently had a darling little girl, they talked for ages about how her name was super unique - it was Cora. Which is a name that is lovely, but not what I was expecting for their 'really unique' name. Or another friend who has a little boy named Andrew Matthew - and I wonder about flow.

    Similarly an old school friend who had a little boy, and she had always (at school and during the pregnancy) talked quite seriously about using Bartholomew, Thaddeus or Hezekiah. And her gorgeous little boy is Jacob.

    Or when you see an announcement for a little Lily, or Ava, or Noah, and sort of think 'it's a lovely name, but there are so many others!'.

    I'm not saying there is anything wrong with these names at all! I generally like all of these names, and even if I didn't it wouldn't matter because it's not my child. And I certainly haven't told any of the parents that I feel their names are at best 'eh, nice' rather than 'stunning'. These names are all great, I just can't help but feel a little disappointed because there are so many incredible names out there and I feel like I'm hearing the same 7 on repeat.

    I'm also aware that many of the names in my signature are probably part of that list, which is partly due to compromise with the (IMO picky with very boring name taste) SO, so I can understand why I meet children where the names may have involved compromise, or they could have family importance.
    But I just feel that pang sometimes when a name is announced. Is it just me? I'm hoping it doesn't make me a bad person.
    Hufflepuff. PhD Student. Cat Lover.
    Alice Marigold. Eliza Avery. Mira Frances. Cleo Jane. Rhea Charnelle.
    Lucas Avery. Isaac William. Oscar George. Jonah Collin. Timothy Edward.

    Annabeth Sparrow. Cynthia Firefly. Eira Solstice. Simon Everest. Hugo Prosper. Benedict Quest.

  2. #3
    Join Date
    Nov 2016
    Posts
    1,058
    I get this when there's like two main names on the list, one that I LOVE and suits the child perfectly and the other that's boring and just eh and the parents choose the eh one. One of the kids I know had Kit Avery as one of his possible names and J0hn M@rkus as the other one and the parents chose John and I literally wanted to scream, especially as he gets older he looks more and more like a Kit and John is the exact opposite of his fun personality. We do call him Jack but I just feel like it's such as waste when his perfect name was one on the list.

    I think as name nerds, especially when it's a friend, we take "bad" or not right names a little harder because we understand the importance and love names, it definitely doesn't make you a bad person.

    Battle Rounds...

    Rivers
    Alessia Rowan Phoenix vs Alessia Juliette Daisy
    Magdalena Mei-ling vs Magdalena Circe
    Evangeline Soleil vs Evangeline Twyla
    Nefertari Sunshine vs Nefertari Diana
    Catalina Shiloh vs Catalina Sofia

    Mountains
    Caspian Archimedes Winter vs Caspian Oliver Atlas
    Theodore Ambrose vs Theodore Calix
    Sebastien Fate vs Sebastien Prosper
    Xavier Stellan vs Xavier Amadeus
    Jasper Oceanside vs Jasper Helios




  3. #5
    Join Date
    May 2013
    Posts
    1,541
    Yes, yes, I know this exact feeling. Of course you love the new little baby and in time the name grows to completely fit the child and you don’t even think about it any more, but I have definitely experienced this “name disappoint” when friends or family have announced their babys names.
    Somewhat similar to your Thaddeus/Hezekiah ended up being Jacob story, a close friend talked about naming her son Paxton, which I think is quite awesome, but ended up giving him a much more generic name like Aiden.
    Zenaida Moonglade|Xiamara Tigerlily|Unity Tamarisk|Saffron Meadowlark|Lavender Daystar|Amethyst Lullaby〰️Koa Boreal|Esker Alpenglow|Castiel Sequoia|Creed Evergreen|Bellamy Tamarack|Adriel Otter

  4. #7
    Join Date
    Jul 2012
    Location
    DC/Virginia
    Posts
    4,044
    There are also those situations where the parents' combo for one gender is much better than their option for the other. A friend of a friend was expecting and had picked something super tryndee and, well, yikes-inducing for a girl, while her boy choice was the much more pleasant Cy. It was such a secondhand relief when she had a boy!
    g w e n

    Viola Mireille Sancia Blue Cosima Vale Zara Fionnuala
    Dash Apollo Madoc Orion Mars Auberon Kieran Adair

    Cameron Alastor Wilde ⋆ Prosper Helio ⋆ Zeke Borealis
    Leonora Maite ⋆ Zola Célimène ⋆ Cleo Amara ⋆ Esmé Octavia Saffron
    v o t e

  5. #9
    Join Date
    Oct 2014
    Location
    Connecticut
    Posts
    1,774
    Yes! I was disappointed to hear my cousin named her son Jaden. I work at a school and hear Jayden/Aiden/Kayden all day long. He's just another Jaden with a last initial.

    Oh also my brother in law just had twins...I haven't met them yet but I heard their names are Fernando and Fernanda. I want to scream in my head.
    Mom to Noemi Xochitl *5/19/14*
    Expecting Kiana Rosalie in December 2017!

    Favorite names at the moment:

    Adela Rosario * Sarai Josefina * Serafina Belen * Valeria Elise * Ximena Daisy

    ☆Zenon (Say-NOHN) * Enrique * Gabriel * Isaiah * Josiah * Zacarias☆

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •