View Poll Results: Given two good names would you choose to use

Voters
28. You may not vote on this poll
  • the best full/formal name

    16 57.14%
  • the name with the best intuitive nickname

    12 42.86%
Page 1 of 2 1 2 LastLast
Results 1 to 5 of 6
  1. #1
    Join Date
    Feb 2012
    Posts
    107

    naming for the sake of a nickname?

    Hi All,

    I'm due in 4 (ish) weeks and stuck with a dilemma. We are a nickname family and an established, traditional nickname is one of my criteria (eg James/Jim). I broke this rule with #3 to use my DH favourite girls name and I do regret it (she has ended up with an inelegant mash-up which our family call her and her full name in public use). I am also aware that the name belongs to the child and they have control over it (#1 has restyled himself with his full name at school while #2 only uses his nickname). That's the background .

    Baby #4 we have settled on 2 boys names which we can both agree with (compromise is the word).

    name A is the more stylish long form name IMO but the nickname is not as elegant, there are 2 possible nn's one I like and one I don't (a similar example would be Andrew/Andy/Drew). Obviously we would use the one I like but as above I don't think we control that once they start school.

    name B has a wonderful nn that I love and which I would use exclusively. I'm not as keen on the full name, there is nothing wrong with it but it seems a bit boring to me. Naturally this is by far my husband's favourite option. I'd get over it if my child wanted to use the formal name but it wouldn't be my choice.

    So long story shorter do you think parents should choose the best formal name or the best nickname if they intend to use a nn? Option B - skipping straight to the nickname would not be considered acceptable where I live and my dh wouldn't have it.

  2. #3
    Join Date
    Jul 2013
    Posts
    5,615
    If other name is just boring, and there's nothing wrong with it, I would go with boring name. It would be different story if you hate or dislike the name.
    Seraphina Isolde Paige Cressida Melody Charlotte Cecily Despina Bridget Rosalyn Cvijeta Dorothea Millicent Gwenllian Beatrice Aurora Rosamund Matilda Nimue Sunniva Giselle Griselda Amoret Helena Anastasia Elaine Isabella Briseis Freya Blanche Paisley Flora Robin Magnus Percy Tristan Ansel Lysander Arthur Edmund Balthazar Dimitri Emil Amaury Erik Dylan Dorian Florian Gustav Harley Roland Ludwig Arlo Orpheus Amadeus Lucius Remy Thorin Hugo Edgar David Beowulf Wesley Roman Sylvan Maximilian Storm

  3. #5
    Join Date
    Jun 2013
    Posts
    3,277
    Believe me, it is possible to go by your nickname all your life. I do such and my name is only on my birth certificate even though I like it. It is so long that everyone tends to shorten it in a nickname I hate. But if you like the traditional nickname, it is nice. Nothing wrong with having a bit boring name I think.
    rosemary helena ۰ basil henry ۰ theda juniper
    nathaniel wilde ۰ magda honey ۰ arthur poet
    agnes thistle ۰ john sherwood ۰ constance darling
    james huckleberry ۰ lydia bambi ۰ archie foxglove
    frances lola ۰ kit barnaby ۰ alice romilly

    ?
    prunella finch ۰ demelza yvaine ۰ polly kestrel
    jack everest ۰ inigo fox ۰ endymion august


  4. #7
    Join Date
    Nov 2013
    Posts
    114
    Because I read your whole dilemma, I voted for the best nickname. To me, it seems like a win-win. You ensure the nickname you like better and your husband gets the name he prefers too. In this case, boring is the safer, better bet (at least that's what I think).

  5. #9
    Join Date
    Jul 2013
    Posts
    646
    Quote Originally Posted by rachelane27 View Post
    Because I read your whole dilemma, I voted for the best nickname. To me, it seems like a win-win. You ensure the nickname you like better and your husband gets the name he prefers too. In this case, boring is the safer, better bet (at least that's what I think).
    I completely agree! This does sound like the best compromise X
    Name lists still under construction

    Holliday Astrid Mabel
    January Iris Aurelia
    Gretel Sunflower/ Ireland Kate
    Fauna Flannery Elizabeth
    Ingrid Lilou Josephine

    Bingham Fox
    Boston
    Bosen
    Saxon

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •