Page 1 of 2 1 2 LastLast
Results 1 to 5 of 6
  1. #1
    Join Date
    Feb 2014

    Aoife and Eva too similar?

    For the last few years my DH and I have been in love with the name Eva, as we knew a little girl with this name.

    Last year my sister had a little girl and called her Aoife (pronounced EE-fa or EE-feh), does that mean it should be off the list? We do see a lot of my sister and her family.

    Your thoughts?

  2. #3
    Join Date
    Jun 2013
    For a second (when I saw the title) I thought you were asking if Aoife and Eva were too similar to be sisters!!!

    If Eva is your number one name and you truly love it, I don't think it's off limits, but I think you should speak to your sister first, explain you've loved the name for years, so she doesn't feel like you're copying her choice.

    If the two girls are likely to spend a lot of time together, and you envisage saying "Aoife and Eva" a lot, you may want to give it some extra thought. Could you use Evie as a nickname, so when they are together they're Aoife and Evie? Could you use a longer form with Eva as a nickname? Evangeline, Evelina, Evanna, Evanthe etc?
    Arthur | Bartholomew | Elias | Ephraim | Ernest | Ferris | Isidore | Phineas | Roland | Rupert | Ted | Victor

    August | Brenna | Eliza | Evanthe | Esmeralda | Freda | Ivy | Mara | Marceline | Matilda | Trudy | Winifred

  3. #5
    Join Date
    Aug 2010
    Gothenburg, Sweden
    It's not optimal but I think it's OK. Talk with your sister first though, and maybe consider a nn like pp's suggestion

    Crushing on
    ♥ Elsie ♥ Molly ♥ Inga ♥ Flora ♥ Rosa ♥ Maj ♥
    ♥ Oscar ♥ Georg ♥ Axel ♥ Viggo ♥ Pelle ♥ Ingo ♥

    among others

    ~ Always dreaming... ~

  4. #7
    Join Date
    Jul 2013
    Unless the name has real significance (honors someone, not just a name I liked), I'd look for something else because *to me* they are too similar.

    If you wouldn't care about the possible confusion when the kids got together, I think you should talk to your sister about it.
    ♥ My Loves ♥
    Emma Angel [07/2009, my angel]
    Bo [08/2009] | Tally [02/2012]
    Octavia Elina [11/2014]

    ♥ Current Favorites ♥
    Alban Shepherd | Ansel Frederick | Leonidas John | Linus Richard | Martin George | Sylvan Jeremiah
    Augusta Plum | Cordelia Iris | Greta Josephine | Matilda June | Miranda Elizabeth | Wilhelmina Eve

  5. #9
    Join Date
    Feb 2014
    Thanks everyone,

    Yes I did think the subject line might make people think that, got your attention though

    You have all listed exactly our concerns and views. We do love the name but I think it is too similar.

    Time to look for some new names we love I think, or maybe another Eve name, great suggestion.

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts