Page 1 of 2 1 2 LastLast
Results 1 to 5 of 8
  1. #1
    Join Date
    Sep 2013
    Location
    Northern Germany
    Posts
    6,570

    Too Close in Sound?

    What's your rule for names that share a sound?
    When are two (or more) names too close to use them together?
    At what point would you eliminate one?

    I'm not talking about Rosalie & Coralie, Amelie & Emily or Nora & Flora, that share half their letters, sound almost identical or rhyme.
    But rather about sets like Rosalie & Ophelia, Leonor & Flora or Clara & Leonora which share a letter combination/sound.

    Do you think they are too close or would they work as sisters?
    Last edited by opheliaflora; March 12th, 2014 at 06:42 PM.


    England 1900 - 1920

    Rosina Millicent, Maud Isabella, Edna Caroline, Alice Dorothy, Rose Amelia, Mary Gwendoline, Mabel Jean

    Nancy Blanche, Iris Barbara, Elsie Winifred, Nora Kathleen, Ruby Eileen, Laura Nellie, Ella Marjorie

    Florence Harriet, Eliza Phyllis, Ida Kate, Minnie May, Ada Miriam, Clara Muriel, Jessie Lillian

    old combos and previous signatures
    https://listography.com/vintagenames

  2. #3
    Join Date
    Mar 2014
    Posts
    381
    I think if they have nn that could be the same, they are too close. My example is i love Eliana and Aviana but what if they both wanna be called Ana? From yours all of them are fine and super cute! Also if they end too close for you, do a variation or make them double barrel/combined names
    No babies anytime soon... Just planning ahead (VERY far ahead)

  3. #5
    Join Date
    Jan 2014
    Posts
    1,606
    Beyond the obvious sharing the nickname or sharing the same beginning (beyond the first letter) or ending (this pertains to sound more than anything), I think it becomes very specific.

    Regarding your examples:

    Rosalie & Ophelia -- this totally works in my opinion and actually the little they share in common actually is what makes them sound good together.

    Leonor & Flora -- The OR sound when encountered in a name is very prominent to me. It stands out and so makes these two too similar for my liking. It makes it sound like a person wanted their children's names to "match" without rhyming. Not a bad thing, just not my style.

    Clara & Leonora -- Again, they share very little in common. They both end in 'ra' but don't share the same overall ending sound. In this case it's more "ara" vs. "ora".

    Again, becomes a kind of case by case thing. Otherwise, I think sometimes names that start and end with the same letter and have the same number of syllables can create a situation where they are just too close, too matchy: Makes them sound like twins to me. Audra & Andra. Is this awful? Absolutely not. Just again, not my style. I like a little more distinction.
    Last edited by aym; March 12th, 2014 at 06:51 PM.

  4. #7
    Join Date
    Mar 2011
    Location
    Northern England
    Posts
    5,212
    Rosalie & Ophelia, Leonor & Flora or Clara & Leonora are all fine to me.
    Rosemary / Briar / Evangeline / Sibyl / Alba

    (im twenty and live in london. names calm my soul.)

    Isidore / Emmett / Hugh / Wilfred / Oberon

  5. #9
    Join Date
    Sep 2013
    Location
    Northern Germany
    Posts
    6,570
    Quote Originally Posted by aym View Post
    Beyond the obvious sharing the nickname or sharing the same beginning (beyond the first letter) or ending (this pertains to sound more than anything), I think it becomes very specific.

    Regarding your examples:

    Rosalie & Ophelia -- this totally works in my opinion and actually the little they share in common actually is what makes them sound good together.

    Leonor & Flora -- The OR sound when encountered in a name is very prominent to me. It stands out and so makes these two too similar for my liking. It makes it sound like a person wanted their children's names to "match" without rhyming. Not a bad thing, just not my style.

    Clara & Leonora -- Again, they share very little in common. They both end in 'ra' but don't share the same overall ending sound. In this case it's more "ara" vs. "ora".

    Again, becomes a kind of case by case thing. Otherwise, I think sometimes names that start and end with the same letter and have the same number of syllables can create a situation where they are just too close, too matchy: Makes them sound like twins to me. Audra & Andra. Is this awful? Absolutely not. Just again, not my style. I like a little more distinction.
    I actually always thought that Rosalie and Ophelia sound closer than Flora and Leonor.
    I'm glad that most of you think that said sets work together because I get bothered when names sound too close and don't want to be a hypocrite, doing the exact same thing.
    (I'm years away from having kids but still...)

    If anyone else want to share their opinion, I'd be glad.


    England 1900 - 1920

    Rosina Millicent, Maud Isabella, Edna Caroline, Alice Dorothy, Rose Amelia, Mary Gwendoline, Mabel Jean

    Nancy Blanche, Iris Barbara, Elsie Winifred, Nora Kathleen, Ruby Eileen, Laura Nellie, Ella Marjorie

    Florence Harriet, Eliza Phyllis, Ida Kate, Minnie May, Ada Miriam, Clara Muriel, Jessie Lillian

    old combos and previous signatures
    https://listography.com/vintagenames

Tags for this Thread

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •