Results 1 to 3 of 3
  1. #1
    Join Date
    Aug 2009

    How important is it?

    How much importance do you put on the meaning of a name? I am loving Gideon, but as a person that is not at all religious I'm not sure if it's weird or not to use a biblical name. I'm also weirded out by the meaning in general. What do you think? If you love the sound is that enough or do you think a name should have a more substantial reason behind its use? Would you use a name that wasn't from the same origin as you or your partner? That last one seems to be something my bf gets stuck on. He's a big believer in using an Irish or English name, seeing as that is where we come from. Before that I really hadn't put much thought into the origins of the names I liked. How important is it?
    Girls: Lucy, Nora, Ivy, Mae, Willow, Rose, Nessa
    Boys: Felix, Philip, Owen, Flynn, Dexter, Henry, Rory, Finlay

  2. #3
    Join Date
    Jul 2013
    I think the actual meaning of the name doesn't matter much. The meaning of your name in no way influences your life or how people feel about you. Of course if your chosen name has a relevant double-meaning (Like the name Melena being also an icky medical term) that might affect modern life. My husband never bothered to find out the meaning of his name until he was in his 20's (and then only because I was so into names I looked it up for him).
    But I will say I do think it's weird to use a religious name from any tradition if you are not a believer. I'd picture a kid named Gideon to come from a traditional conservative Christian household & I think if you choose a religious name you may be setting your child up to be stereotyped.
    I would use a name that is not from my own origins geographically but not one so blatantly religious as Gideon (I don't see the appeal by the way).

    I strongly prefer the boys' names in your sig, especially Owen, Flynn, Dexter, Rory & Finlay.
    New username is @ truenature

  3. #5
    Join Date
    Mar 2012
    I love the name Gideon and I like it's rhythm, which is a rhythm I gravitate to for both girls (Vivien, Imogen...) and boys, while being less well-used than Jonathan or Sebastian.

    But I am kind of religious and I don't mind that coming across, though I am not Christian or British and I don't know if that would change it for me.

    To me that's not the meaning, anyway, its just the background. I know a Rafael ("G-d will heal") born to atheist parents. That's more striking to me as far as meaning than Gideon, which means warrior or tree-cutter. I can think of a lot of very mainstream names, like Daniel/Michael/Christopher that have more religious meanings than Gideon does. Whether the background, however, worries you as far as coming across as from a religious family, is different. And honestly I don't know how it would be seen.

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts