Page 1 of 2 1 2 LastLast
Results 1 to 5 of 8
  1. #1
    Join Date
    Nov 2012

    How much is too much name?

    Okay, I must admit. I was daydreaming the other day about what I would name a July 4th Independence Day baby. I settled on Amaryllis and paired it with the wonderful Josephine. Amaryllis Josephine is already a longer name, but nothing tragic. But then there's the second middle, which I really wanted to use Liberty! So patriotic, makes me think of this beautiful country. But then I had:

    Amaryllis Josephine Liberty

    Let's say this girl has a short last name, 1 syllable. Does this work, or is it entirely too much name?

    Other combos:
    Amaryllis Liberty Jolie - not liking how Amaryllis flows into Liberty. sounds like sliberty to me.
    Amaryllis Josephine Saoirse (sare-sha) - It's a lot of S's. What I love is that Saoirse means liberty, though!
    Amaryllis Josephine Summer - also a lot of S's, and no patriotic reference.
    Amaryllis Jane Liberty - I think this flows really well, but...well, I really wanted Josephine!

    1. Is Amaryllis Josephine Liberty nice or too much?
    2. Do you prefer any of the alternatives?
    3. Any other suggestions?


    Amaryllis * Holiday * Cordelia * Waverly * Seraphina * Calliope * Olympia * Zephyrine * Genevieve * Marguerite

    Phineas * Caspian * Orlando * Florian * Sullivan * Laszlo * Thaddeus * Virgil * Ozias * Ambrose

  2. #3
    Join Date
    Nov 2012
    Still no replies?

  3. #5
    Join Date
    Apr 2013
    I think it's cute. Liberty is a bit much, I mean I would have just done Liberty Josephine and called it good, Amaryllis has an awkward sound and flow to me.

    As far as too much name goes, that depends entirely on you. I'm a fan of the concise, so I'd prefer to find a way to cram everything I like into a first or middle, or a sibset if it's too much. I'm a one-middle-name type person, especially since I have an irrational distaste of hyphens.
    I'm not feeling incredibly profound at the moment. Check back later.

  4. #7
    I tend to feel more than two given names is too much name unless they're very short or you need to squeeze in family names for some reason, so not really sure how to address the question.

  5. #9
    Join Date
    Feb 2012
    I think its fine maybe a little long but nothing too crazy.

    I think 4 or more names is too long personally.
    Like Arthur Frederick William Benedict would be way too long
    Raquel-23 year old who loves names, books, and languages

    Ladies: Clara Josephine, Amelia Juliet, Louisa Genevieve, Rose Caroline, Charlotte Rosamund, Eleanora Winter, Marina Adelaide, Emmeline Margot, Alice Primrose,Annabel Frances, Catherine Isabella, Vivienne Lucille
    Gentlemen: Frederick Arthur Louis, Nicholas Hugo, Henry Oliver, William Grey, Matthew Isaiah, Thomas Alaric, George Everett, Edmund Tobias, Asher Benjamin, and James Raphael

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts