Had twice as many before DH vetoed half. Thoughts on remaining list?

[random]

Changed my mind: Isla Jocelyn is my new fav! :-)

[mydearcuriosity]

Lily or Miriam would be stunning imo.

[em_crazynamer]

Blythe - cute but doesn't fit with trendy Caleb and cute Annabel.
Daisy - cute mn but not first. Doesn't age well.
Elizabeth - adorable!! Nn Eliza?!?! Caleb, Annabel and Eliza is precious.
Faith - maybe use as a mn to fit with Annabel Hope. NMS much.
Isla - love it. My favourite name. Caleb, Annabel and Isla is so cute.
Jane - a little boring. Plain Jane. MN maybe. Much better names on your list.
Jocelyn - I really hate this name. I think the Lynn bit sounds dated and IDK a tacky name maybe. Sorry. :/
Lily - love Lily so much. Totally fits with Annabel!! Caleb, Annabel and Lily cute.
Madeleine - boring I think.
Madeline - same as above.
Maisie - cute but too whimsical I think for Caleb and Annabel.
Miranda - NMS at all. Sex in the City character and I knew a girl named Miranda and everyone called her Randy. Ew IMO.
Miriam - too old-ladyish for your sibset.
Molly - cute. Sounds like a dogs name to me.
Phoebe - very cute. Caleb, Annabel and Phoebe is adorable.
Rose - cute but not your best.
Sabrina - THE TEENAGE WITCH.
Tabitha - meh.
Victoria - boring.
Violet - cute!! Caleb, Annabel and Violet is very cute!!

Favourites are:
Eliza
Isla
Lily
Phoebe
Violet

(ironically all these names are on my personal list )

[skateblinder]

First of all Caleb and Annabel are lovely names, and you have some great choices here. I think Elizabeth would work really well, it is a longer name like Annabel with multilple nicknames, also like Annabel. Faith would be a nice choice, Jocelyn would be lovely! Sabrina and Tabitha would also work well. I honestly think you have some great names here, so what every you choose would be great.

[juma1234]

I think with Caleb Nicholas and Annabel Hope, Elizabeth Anne and Madeleine Rose go really well.

[krismichelle]

Thanks, all, for the responses! I asked DH about Eleanor and Marina, and they're both no-goes. I think his favorites at the moment are Elizabeth and Lily. My favorites change hourly. :lol:

[davisellu]

My favorite from your list and with your sibset was Jocelyn-- I think Jocelyn Faith would work very nicely.

[encore]

Elizabeth
Faith
Jane
Lily
Madeleine
Miranda
Molly
Sabrina
Victoria
Violet

those are the ones I like but my favorites to fit with Caleb and Annabel are Elizabeth, Faith, Jane and Lily.

[ashthedreamer]

I love your list! With Caleb and Annabel, Violet is probably my favorite but I also really like Madeleine, Jocelyn, Lily, Phoebe, and Blythe. I think Madeleine Blythe, Violet Blythe/Violet Madeleine, Jocelyn Phoebe, Phoebe Blythe, Lily Madeleine, or Blythe Madeleine would all be fabulous. Madeleine Blythe is my favorite combo, but Violet is my favorite FN with Caleb and Annabel.

Good luck!

ETA: I adore Elizabeth, too, and I think Elizabeth Blythe would be lovely with Caleb Nicholas and Annabel Hope. I think Elizabeth's nns are lovely, too (Ella/Elle, Libby, Eliza, Elise, Izzy, Ibby, Beth, Betty, Bit/Bitty, Tilly, Tess, etc.), and most go so well with Caleb and Annabel!

[rollo]

Miranda Blythe like nn of Miri
Isla Faith
Faith Madeline (leen)
VictoriaLily
Jocelyn Rose
Jocelyn Miranda
Phoebe Anastasia
Blythe Daisy
Daisy Mirabelle
Violet Rose
Miriam Violet
Marguerite Lily nn Molly

good luck hope you like one of these combos!!!

And Violet is lovely with Annabel and Caleb