Results 1 to 5 of 10
Thread: Madeleine vs Marianne
February 3rd, 2014 08:08 AM #1Junior Member
- Join Date
- Jan 2014
Madeleine vs Marianne
DH and I went over our respective baby girl lists on the weekend, we're due in 7 weeks. We've narrowed it down to two options, both of which I can imagine on a daughter. But now I'm obsessing over them!
My obsessing: I love Marianne for it's vintage feel. It seems graceful, sweet and refreshing. But is it plain and boring? Or does it's classic quality and fact that it isn't used very often cancel out boring? We would use Annie for NN.
I think that I like Madeleine more but it has more complicating features for me. 2 yo DD has a name that we totally love but there are 2 spellings and 2 prononciations. 50% of people both misspell and mispronounce her name all the time- even family members- which is annoying. We're setting ourselves up for this with Madeline/Madeleine. I like the NN Leni better than Maddy but also feel like we'd be fighting against Maddy.
Would love your thoughts on Marianne vs Madeleine!
February 3rd, 2014 08:44 AM #3Piers Lachlan | Gray Everett | Tadhg Wilder
Jack Wilder | Henry Birch | Charlie Hawthorne
Maebry Elizabeth Posy | Eloise Margaret Birdie | Coralie Jane Magnolia
Sophie Jane Magnolia | Emma Eloise Maebry | Isabel Margaret Birdie "Isby"
❤ heart my son ❤
February 3rd, 2014 09:49 AM #5Member
- Join Date
- Sep 2012
February 3rd, 2014 09:54 AM #7
I love Marianne more than Madeleine, Madeleine is beautiful, but you'd definitely have issues with Maddy, unless you introduce her as Leni/Eleni. I also agree that Evangeline doesn't fit.
If Evangeline has to stay, what about Marina Evangeline?
Marianne Angelique (AHN-gel-eek) would work nicely too.Ladies: Florence ❀ Doris ❀ Harriet ❀ Minnie ❀ Martha ❀ Evelyn ❀ Lottie ❀ Elsie ❀ Lillian ❀ Beatrice ❀ Violet ❀
Gentlemen: Charlie ❀ Matthew ❀ Ernest ❀ Albert ❀ Daniel ❀ Harry ❀ Darragh ❀ Andrew ❀ Louis ❀ Cameron ❀
February 3rd, 2014 12:20 PM #9Junior Member
- Join Date
- Feb 2014
I'm guessing you're Acadian based on your user name so I understand the significance of Evangeline for you! I prefer Marianne Evangeline. I don't see (or hear) a flow problem, but in any case, how well a first name and middle name flow together is really, really insignificant in the real world (outside of name forums, that is).
You will still get some spelling confusion with Marianne - people will spell it Marie-Anne or Mary Anne etc. - but at least you are unlikely to have people mispronouncing it when they see it on paper, as you might with Madeleine.
I don't think you can go wrong either way as they're both very nice names, but if you really dislike Maddie I'd probably stay away from Madeleine.