Results 31 to 35 of 62
July 17th, 2013 12:39 PM #31
July 17th, 2013 01:04 PM #33
I might be alone in this, but I don't think that this is such a big problem on here. I think the majority of the berries are so lovely and helpful, but also honest which I think is a good thing when asking about opinions (but again, that might just be me). You can't ask for opinions on a name and expect everyone to compliment it. There are so many people on here with a different taste than yours and sometimes it can be nice with a new point of view of things (that said, obviously it's not necessary to lambast the name(s)/user completely). I also think that people should remember that it's not a personal attack on you if someone don't like your favourite name or say that they hate it (or whatever). It's funny because on another forum (royalty-related, obviously) I am a member of, we were discussing the future name of Baby Cambridge and someone had mentioned how they hoped William and Catherine wouldn't use a specific name because of one of its nicknames and several people agreed with that. Then another poster felt a bit hurt because the nickname that people didn't like happened to be her name, but it really wasn't a personal vendetta against her or anyone else named *name*, it was merely stating that they didn't like the name.
Generally I try not to post in threads where the TS has a completely different style than me because that wouldn't be helpful at all (and I'm also ridiculously bad at suggesting names, so I think I do everyone a favour by staying away from threads where I don't even like the names mentioned in the OP)Zelia • XXI • History student • Film and royalty enthusiastI run vesperlynds and everythingroyalty, and export names from Greenland and Inuit mythology
Henry Ásgeirr Lórien • Alexander Adelin Pemba "Sasha" • Atticus Aksel Ivik • Oscar Llŷr Igaluk
Cosima Ingrid Zenobia "Mimi" • Asta Ivalo (EE-vah-lu) Galadriel • Aviaaja Catherine Françoise "Avi" • Evelyn Alvaret Cleopatra "Elví"
GPs: Nor Valdemar Oisín • Bertil Cosimo Edmund • Olga Agnes Lúthien • Alva Madicken Héloïse
July 17th, 2013 01:35 PM #35
Yeah, I don't know why, but I have been noticing a lot of that also. For example, I really don't like the name Phyllis at all. But I'm not going to tell someone that their child will be scarred forever if they choose that name, because they won't. Who knows but that their child will love that name and be eternally grateful for it. So, my response would be something along the lines of, "It's nice but I don't really like it myself".
P.S. No offense meant to any Phyllis's : )Arthur Isidore-Fox Malachi-Jules Balthasar-Percy Raphael
Petra Geneviève-Zélie Margarethe ♠ Luna Célimène-Aliénor Fatime
July 17th, 2013 01:43 PM #37
If you read the original post, you'll see that the sentiment wasn't that everyone should only ever say when they like a name, and no one should ever criticize a name, but that criticism should be constructive and thoughtful.
And yes, most berries are quite helpful. But I've seen several (many?) threads lately in which a proposed name--often a unique, unusual, or otherwise non-Nameberry name, often proposed by a new member--is blasted and then about 30 posters pile on with comments that aren't constructive or helpful in the slightest. I do think that's a problem because it shuts out new ideas and perspectives.human children:
holden timothy | huckleberry jude
penelope | puck | sofia
July 17th, 2013 01:54 PM #39
I agree tawnysaurus. It's seems like we're talking about several different things, which is fine and I like hearing about why people post the way they do. But I know you didn't mean "WARM FUZZIES ONLY!"Baby #2 due April 2016