Results 1 to 5 of 14
Thread: Thoughts on Vintage Girl Names
March 16th, 2013 07:44 PM #1Member
- Join Date
- Mar 2013
Thoughts on Vintage Girl Names
I am wanting to see what all of the name lovers out there think about some of the names I have picked out for a girl. I love the different vintage names. I don't overly care for the more trendy and popular names. Vintage, though, seems to be coming more popular so that is both good and bad for me. Good because I love the names, but bad because the names I like are too old sounding. Or so I have been told. It will be good to hear what other people think that are not family members who are over thinking the names. ( Though rightfully so :)
So here are a few:
The two I get the most criticism about are Judith and Ethel. Edith, I know, is becoming more popular. So why would Ethel and Judith not be liked as much as Edith?
Thanks for your thoughts!
March 16th, 2013 07:52 PM #3
I adore vintage names for boys and girls! Edith is gorgeous. I think Ethel and Judith will become more likeable very soon! Lily Allen named her daughter Ethel, and she's pretty cool, so the name is bound to increase in popularity! Other vintage girls names I adore:
Last edited by sarahmezz; March 16th, 2013 at 07:55 PM.~ Mother of Violet Elizabeth Rose ~
FUTURE DAUGHTER: AUDREY, DAPHNE OR IVY
FUTURE SON: FREDERICK, HENRY OR THEODORE
March 16th, 2013 07:52 PM #5Mother of three teenagers: (1) Daniel Glen, (2) Timothy Austin, and (3) Rebecca Jane. All middle names honor family, with Jane used three generations in a row. (A second girl would have been Susanna Eve).
March 16th, 2013 07:58 PM #7
Judith and Ethel are NMS, but I can definitely see the appeal. However, Judith and Ethel don't have the ultra cute, modern nickname Edie- an nn that fits right in with Evie and Ella and Ellie. Judy is still very middle aged and old.
Generally, outside name message boards, vintage names are frowned upon, hence -aydens and -sons on girls that flood the name lists. In most places, Edith is still seen as an old lady name.
I think it is still to early for Judith, but ever since a celebrty Lily Allen chose Ethel Mary a year or so ago, I think Ethel is in the realm of possibility. But Judith does have a solemn ring that sounds nice to me.
Don't let family members influence you, unless one of them happens to be an active Berry or studies name etymology. Try not to share your name choices. Granted, this is not my experience, but I've heard one too many horror stories about parents to be being convinced out of their favorite name by relatives.~lucy reine~~ celestine eira ~ mary simona ~ elizabeth echo "ellie" ~ eleanor maeve "lena" ~ vivienne isla ~ celia matilda "cici" ~ catherine aiko "rin" ~ elsa verity ~~ jasper red ~ evander lachlan 'evan'~ kai nicholas ~ ezra link ~ avery thomas ~ michael satoshi "mischa" ~ finn jeremias ~ ezekiel hayden ~ alexander rowan "sacha" ~
~ tisiphone aria ~ alecto elpis ~ miya lucida ~ addison matteo ~ corinthian tidus ~
March 16th, 2013 08:03 PM #9Senior Member
- Join Date
- Dec 2011
Edith has the awesome nickname Edie!
Judith sounds so stuffy and snobby. Judy is pretty, but I do not like Judith.
Ethel sounds awful. It belongs with names like Bertha, Beulah and Helga.
I like most vintage names, but some of them are just not very pretty and I don't think they should be used anymore.
If I had to change my name to either Edith, Ethel or Judith, I would definitely pick Edith.