View Poll Results: Which name do you like best?
- 44. You may not vote on this poll
Results 1 to 5 of 10
January 11th, 2013 11:05 AM #1
Need help picking a first name for a possible son
Deciding on our girl choices was easy. We pretty much agreed right away that if this baby is a girl, her name would be either Catherine/Katherine or Elizabeth. But if it's a boy, we can't seem to decide between William, Alexander, Benjamin, or Sebastian. (If the decision was entirely up to me, he'd be Nicholas Alexander, but DH doesn't want to use Nicholas in the first spot because our nephew's name is Colin, which is a form of Nicholas.)
William: Has always been a long-time favorite for me -- I love it almost as much as Nicholas -- but I've been thinking that maybe we shouldn't use it in a sibset with possible future sisters Catherine and Elizabeth. Would that scream too much "British royal family", or are the names common enough that it doesn't really matter?
Alexander: A family name on both sides, but we can't seem to agree on the nickname. Hubby likes Alex, and only Alex, while I really love Xander or Sasha.
Benjamin: There are really no major problems with this name, except that I don't love it quite as much as William and Alexander.
Sebastian: I have a HUGE name crush on him lately, but I'm not sure if it'll turn out to be a lifetime love. Also, I'm not sure if he quite matches the classic, traditional style we like. Maybe better as a middle name?
Last edited by mega_muffin; January 11th, 2013 at 11:10 AM.
January 11th, 2013 11:24 AM #3
January 11th, 2013 01:48 PM #5Senior Member
- Join Date
- Mar 2012
I'd go with William since you both seem to really like it and don't have nickname issues with it.
I think that it's classic enough not to seem weird with a Catherine or Elizabeth
Also - is there any way to convince DH to consider Nicholas? I only ask because I had no idea that Colin was a form of Nicholas. If I met a Colin and a Nicholas I would not even think twice about it.
January 11th, 2013 01:51 PM #7Senior Member
My Top Names:
- Join Date
- Dec 2011
Bernice, Clara, Harlow, Harper, Lillian, Mabel, Rosemarie
Alden, Davis, Glenn, Eugene, Harley, Peter, Rudy
January 11th, 2013 05:14 PM #9
With Catherine/Katherine I LOVE William and Benjamin. (Benjamin only the slightest bit more)
In all honesty all of your choices for both girls and boys can be made into great sibsets . . . I don't see one name that would be out of place (MAYBE Sebastian and Katherine could be a bit rhymey, but even this seems fine to me).
Oh, in addition William and Catherine seem more classic, conservative, and elegant to me - rather than "royal family". I love this sibset!
Alexander Owen ~ Patrick Thomas ~ Jack ~ Conor ~ Nolan ~ Mark ~ Samuel ~ Jeremy ~ Ian ~ Vincent ~ Evan
Nora ~ Claire ~ Stella ~ Madeleine ~ Violet ~ Victoria ~ Ava ~ Gabrielle ~ Leah ~ Soleil