Results 11 to 15 of 28
Thread: Honest Thoughts on Eloide
January 10th, 2013 07:37 PM #11Senior Member
- Join Date
- Jan 2013
Married to my high school sweetheart
Mother to Charles Nathaniel aka Charlie [1.26.09]
Baby due [3.17.13]
January 10th, 2013 09:17 PM #13Senior Member
- Join Date
- Mar 2012
I find Elodie a bit grating, honestly.
I'd prefer Emily or Elizabeth despite the popularity. As long as they're spelt right I think of them as classics, perennials that are unapologetic about being around forever. Both haven't dropped off the Social Security Top 100 in over 130 years, to me that's not trendy.
What about less-common Elizabeth variants, like Eliza or Elspeth?
January 10th, 2013 09:33 PM #15
My thought is this: although Elodie appears to have some legit historical origins, it comes off as made up and trendy. I would much prefer Melody, and Eloise is another superior choice (IMO of course.) Perhaps Elodie's history is just too obscure to make it more common-place, like the name Iris is, (another Greek name.) Elodie is very similar to the name Phaedra (yet another with Greek roots) in that respect. Both have legit historical origins, but are basically unheard of. They sound and look made up. If that doesn't bother you, then go for it! Elodie is both aesthetically pleasing and pleasant to hear.One Beloved Son - Raphael David
Saved for Later:
Rosemary, Phaedra, Lorena, Georgia, Theodora
Ignatius, Lionel, Thaddeus, Laszlo, Caspian
January 11th, 2013 08:20 AM #17Senior Member
- Join Date
- Jul 2012
REMINDER: TALKING ABOUT ELODIE, NOT ELOIDE...TYPO IN TITLE.
I guess the Melody v. Elodie confusion (really don't know where Jodie came from...they sound totally different) doesn't totally bother me. I go by my middle name, which is one letter off from a boy name (it is NOT a boys or unisex name in any way, was just never a popular girls name so people rarely see it) and I will SAY my name....and even after that, if they see the name they don't see the spelling and will still call me the boys name.
So anyway, I've gone my whole life being called a boy name, so to me it might be a slight annoyance but definitely not a deal-breaker.
But, I agree that I like Eloise more than Elodie. Decisions, decisions!
It's just funny because I never minded going by an uncommon name people never got right (maybe because it's an easy name so I just felt like the people were idiots?)....after all, my first name was Jessica and in kindergarten I insisted I go by my uncommon middle name. However, my husband has an basically unheard of name in the US that people always butcher so I think he likes things that are common and everywhere that no one will get wrong.
Last edited by 2gsdchildren; January 11th, 2013 at 11:18 AM.
January 11th, 2013 09:07 AM #19
Elodie does not come off at trendy to me. It's been a well established name for century that stems from the Spanish Alodia and it feels perfectly substantial and sophisticated to me. Then again, I've been familiar with this name for quite some time. However, just because some people think it sounds trendy doesn't mean it is!
Eloise is also quite nice. I've always grouped Elodie and Eloise together in my mind as "those pretty, somewhat uncommon French E names". I don't think you can go wrong with either one, so I would go with the one you can imagine yourself calling out more easily. Emily and Elizabeth are nice, but so common.Loving right now:
Eulalie Catherine, Cordelia Iseult, Cosima Beatrix, Cecily Morgana
Ivo Marius, Euan Casper, Remy Nathaneal, Crispin Adair