Still searching for Mattie's sister

[calliem]

I love Bonnie as well but my husband has a cousin named Bonnie. We both have rather large families so I feel like a lot of names have already been "taken" like Sophie and Bonnie. I also very briefly dated a guy who now has a daughter with one of the names we are considering but he used a different spelling. We live in the same town and it is possible to run into each other at some point. Would it be awkward to have a daughter with the same name but different spelling? Sadie seems to be at the top of our list but I feel like we would be limiting ourselves even more by going with another vintage nickname name. I really love Willa Juliet but my husband is reluctant, he doesn't feel like it's "the one".

[lori johnson]

Vintage nickname names ...

Mattie [and] Effie

[or]

Mattie [and] Libby

[or]

Mattie [and] Sadie

[or]

Mattie [and] Sophie

are optimal.


Additionally, you might consider ...

Mattie Mae [and] Lindy Lou
Mattie Mae [and] Lottie Lou
Mattie Mae [and] Lucy Lou [my current favorite for you]
Mattie Mae [and] Lydie Lou


More vintage nickname names ...

http://nameberry.com/blog/vintage-ni...-girls-edition [and] http://nameberry.com/list/222/Vintag...ames-for-Girls

[elizabeth1]

My favourites from your list:
*Hannah
*Isla
*Charlotte (love the name, but not sure of the sibset with Mattie)
*Juliet (this is probably my number one favourite!)
I agree with your husband on Willow, as it's one of my favourites. But if you don’t like it then it's out . I’m not a fan at all of Effie

[calliem]

As much as I want to stay away from another vintage nickname name, it seems like our favorites are Sylvie and Sadie. What do you all think of these combinations?
Sylvie Isla
Isla Sylvie
Lila Sylvie
Sylvie Juliet
Sadie Juliet
Hannah Sylvie
Hannah Jane
Aria Juliet

[flick]

I love Hannah with Mattie.

[mikaelam]

I love Mattie and Isla together!! You have a great list!

[marissalou]

Mattie Mae and:

Isla Kate
Charlotte Grey
Amelia Vivian
Willa Mabel
Olivia Kate
Emma Lou
or
Sylvie Annabel

Hope that helps!

[calliem]

Great suggestions marissalou! Thank you! I love them all but my husband has nixed Willa. I am really in love with Isla, Sylvie, Hannah, Sadie, Juliet and Amelia right now. Is Hannah too common and boring? We seem to keep coming back to it.