Shocked even myself....

[namelover77]

I love it! I've met a young Natalie, but only once. You could call her Tallie (probably Tilly, too) or maybe Nellie. It's a lovely name. I think Natalie Samara or Natalie Sonata/Sonatina is really pretty!

[saraallison]

I love Natalie too. It's so great. I know a 4 yr old Natalie in my sons preschool. Def not weird to use it if the baby is born in a season other than winter. It's not like people will ask her, oh are you a Xmas baby? Or if they do, I find that strange. Your mn style is different from mine, but of other suggestions here I like Natalie Violet, Natalie Plum and Natalie Clara!

[kibby]

I found the root to Andrews problem! It's not the nontraditional names but thr fact that they are too short. I suggested Magnolia and Lavender and he said they flow better compared to the shorter name as the berry who suggested Magnolia also pointed out! But now I am stumped because all the names I have been loving so far are shorter names! Though, we decided Natalie Jane will be our fallback name if we can't agree on another, but it just feels soooo plain.

[sadlola]

Maybe:
Natalie Amethyst
Natalie Delilah
Natalie Juniper
Natalie Camellia
Natalie Primrose
Natalie Rosemary
Natalie Amaryllis

hmmm... I do like Natalie Jane too.

[characternamer]

I love Natalie! I wouldn't put it on my list, because of too many associations (All good ones, but I think of friends with the name when I hear it). One of those names that you love seeing on someone else's list. I don't think it would be weird to have on a non-winter baby, I actually didn't know it had a winter meaning. There are two Natalies in my grade (I'm NOW in 8th grade), and my friend has a little sister named Natalie, who's in fifth grade now.
My favorite combos are:
Natalie Rue
Natalie Rain
Natalie Rowen
Natalie Rosa/Rose
Natalie Ro/Row
I just really like Natalie with an R middle name, I guess!

[kibby]

What about-------
Natalie Lilah
Natalie Evelyn
Natalie Beatrice or Bellatrix
Natalie Eleanor
Natalie Eden
Natalie Delphine
Natalie Virginia
Natalie Katerina
Natalie Linnea
Natalie March
Natalie Quinn
Natalie Priscilla
Natalie Romilly
Natalie Rowan

More to come likely!!

[saracita00]

If you like Rue but not the meaning, maybe Ruth instead?

Here is a Z name you might like -- Zuzannah.

Some 4-syllable names I found...
Anastasia
Amaryllis
Arianna
Aristana
Begonia
Cassiopeia
Cecilia
Celestina
Cordelia
Dulcinea
Eleanora
Elizabeth
Esmerelda
Felicity
Geranium
Iolanthe
Indiana
Juliana
Lavinia
Lilliana
Madalena
Magdalena
Mahogany
Mariposa (this means butterfly)
Olivia
Olympia
Roselina
Seraphina
Sophronia
Tanazia
Veronica
Victoria
Violetta
Viviana
Xiamara

[dantea]

I think Natalie is a bit of a weird mic with your boys names and other girl names and I think Natalia would go better, but I'm glad you found a name that you love so much! I know quite a lot of Natalie's and they're all pretty awful. I like Natalie Snow, it's very pretty

Here's some naturey, floral, word names for the middle ^_^

Natalie Aerith -- Latin for Air
Natalie Gaia
Natalie Ember
Natalie Sorcha -- welsh for bright fire
Natalie Calantha -- beautiful blossom
Natalie Clover
Natalie Fern
Natalie Iris
Natalie Primrose
Natalie Cypress
Natalie Rain
Natalie Sky
Natalie Wren
Natalie Silvana -- from the forest
Natalie Xylia -- forest dweller
Natalie Danica -- morning star
Natalie Jasmine
Natalie Willow
Natalie Soleil
Natalie Solana
Natalie Echo
Natalie Blithe
Natalie Cadence
Natalie Fawn
Natalie Jade
Natalie Poet
Natalie Sonnet
Natalie Saga
Natalie Fable
Natalie Scout
Natalie Star
Natalie True

Here's some Irish ones because I know you like Irish names:

Natalie Bridget
Natalie Eithne/Enya
Natalie Fiona
Natalie Radha (row-ah)
Natalie Roisin (ro-sheen)
Natalie Siobhan (shiv-awn)

Greek myth names, because I know you like them:

Natalie Athena
Natalie Hemera -- goddess of daylight
Natalie Thalassa -- spirit of the sea
Natalie Selene -- titan of the moon, commonly pronounced sel-leen, pronounced sel-leen-ee in Greek
Natalie Eunomia -- Goddess of good order and lawful conduct -- u-no-mee-a
Natalie Eupraxia -- spirit of well-being
Natalie Soteria -- female personification of safety, preservation and deliverance from harm
Natalie Calypso -- I know you love it! It sounds really good with Natalie and Natalie grounds it. Go for it!
Natalie Clio -- Olympian muse of history
Natalie Cassandra
Natalie Helen
Natalie Phaedra
Natalie Myrina -- queen of the amazons


Do you like any of those?

[judyariel]

Some more ideas:
Natalie Arabelle
Natalia Arabella
Natalie Antoinette
Natalie Antonia
Natalie Hyacinth
Natalie Alessandra
Natalie Genevieve
Natalie Guinevere
Natalie Artemis
Natalie Artemisia
Natalie Francesca
Natalie Xaviera
Natalie Oriana
Natalie Octavia
Natalie Ophelia
Natalie Angelica
Natalie Angelique
Natalie Dominique
Natalie Coraline
Natalie Christabel
Natalie Jessamine
Natalie Jacinda
Natalie Millicent
Natalie Wilhelmina
Natalie Isadora
Natalie Teodora
Natalie Emmeline
Natalie Rosalia
Natalie Rosaline
Natalia Aviana
Natalie Melisande
Natalie Philomena
Natalie Phaedra
Natalie Rosabel/Natalie Rosabelle
Natalie Wilhelmina
Natalie Dorothea
Natalie Seraphine
Natalie Vivienne

[catheyc]

I love Natalie. I don't think it's plain at all and none of the ones I know were born around Christmas. I love Natalie Winter, but my favorite that someone mentioned was Natalie Violet. I also LOVE Natalie Jane, but I know your hubby doesn't like the short ones. Maybe he's reconsider for a family name? That just has such a great ring to it.

Although I'm hesitant to say so (because I absolutely hate boys' names going to the girls), it really seems like the perfect name for your, so I'll throw it out there (someone may have already mentioned it; I didn't read all the posts): Natalie Rowan? It certainly does have a nice sound to it. Maybe to "girl" it up a little bit (and add a syllable for your DH), Natalie Rowena? Technically it has a different meaning, but I think it's a lovely combination.