Vintage girl names, which one is best?

[anathema]

For fear of spamming, this'll be my second and final post for the day.

PRONUNCIATIONS:
Eilis - "Eye-Lish"
Eugenia - "You-Gee-Nee-Uh"
Cathryn - "Cath-Rin"
Kearney - "Car-Nee"

[jennipea382]

I voted for Brigid but I prefer Bridget :-)

[svea]

I voted for Lucinda with Imogen as a close second

[dedutchess]

I voted for Meredith!

[elisabeth rae]

I love Imogen, and Jane is a close second. I love Bridget but am not crazy about Brigid. You have a lot of nice choices

[momberry]

I LOVE Meredith the most followed by Bridget (prefer over Brigid)

[mischa]

I love the strength and beauty of Meredith Kearney!

[kala_way]

I voted for Beatrice because it's lovely and I like the nn's. Bea, Tric (Trish), Trix, Trixie, Atti
I also like Jane a lot.
I like Lucy, but I don't think it goes with your surname.

[ashthedreamer]

I voted for Anne Cathryn, but I nearly voted for Jane.

I'm guessing this is for you, though? As someone who's considered changing their name, though, I have to ask, do you think all of these fit you the same way? When I had considered changing my name, I had about 4 solid options, and none of them fit me the same way, or, ultimately, perfectly (which is why I dropped the idea. That, and I have grown to love my name, haha). Since we really don't know you, we couldn't say which would fit you perfectly. I don't know if it's important to you, but it definitely was important to me to find a name that both suited me perfectly and that I loved enough that I could imagine living with it for the next 60-70 years. But if you're just looking for opinions on the names, I definitely like Anne (nn Annie) and Jane the best.