Sylvie and Vivi seem a little bit close as sisters for me, with the -vee sound in both names. Sylvie, Josie and Milly work better than Sylvie, Josie and Vivi, I feel.
As for nicknames for Elizabeth, there's a ton. The most common ones are Liz/zie, Libby, Ellie, Beth, Eliza and Liza - like any of those?
I like Ellie and Lizzie but fear they are so common. Sylvie and. Josie are somewhat unique and I don't want there to be 2 or three Elizabeth's in her grade. Not that it's a huge deal but I grew up as the only. Molly in my grade.
I agree Vivian works but Vivi seems a lot like Sylvie because of the "v" sound.
I like Milly but don't know how to get there. Amelia my husband does not love and he hates Mildred
We both love Aggie but Agnes is growing on us.
This naming stuff is hard
My vote was Elizabeth.
Sylvie, Josie, and Libby- My favorite
Sylvie, Josie, and Lizzie- adore this
Sylvie, Josie, and Ellie- Like
Sylvie, Josie, and Vivi- I agree with PP the "vi" is a little close
Sylvie, Josie, and Milly- Do you like Millie? Seems like it would flow with the spellings of the others better.
I do like Millie
So I think martha is off the list. I am fine with that. And I feel like we finally have some solid names to start to throw around, and see what sticks. I know it sounds weird but we try saying them aloud to see if anyone of them sounds right.
Just one last question because this has been my most helpful thread ever. Is there a name that is not on this list that you think we are missing that would be absolutely perfect for us?