If Ebenezer didn't have such a negative association it would absolutely be at the top of my list.
I also like Elias and Edgar.
I'd be most likely to use Eli.
I also really like Ember and Emory, though they do feel like copycats of Amber and Emily.
Similarly, I think Emmaus is very pretty.
Despite it's trendiness I think Ever and Everly are truly beautiful, and I hope they hold on past the -ly and word trend.
One of my all time favorites is simple Eve. I love it's meaning and history and simplicity.
But of all of them, the one I'd most likely use is Evelyn.
Erasmus* (love this one)