Finley Marie- Finley still tips more male to me. If you use Finley use a middle name that doesn't end in an "ey" sound. Especially not Marie, it's such a filler. Finley Gabriella, Finley Grace, Finley Sara.
Claire Bronwyn- I prefer Bronwyn Claire. I think you should add another middle name. The balance feels off.
Makiya Grace- Makiya is a made up name, I really don't like it. Michaela is more suitable and is a legitimate name.
Carleigh- Dear god this is horrid. Go with Carly.
Claire Faith- I like the suggestion of Clarissa Faith.
The only one I like is Claire Faith.
Everything else sounds uber trendy or too masculine.
Claire Faith is timeless.
Finley Marie- Very cute
Carleigh Bronwyn- I hate the spelling you chose for the first name, I'd prefer Carly, Carley, or Carlie. Bronwyn is lovely and unique.
Claire Faith- Love the name Claire! Very pretty.
Makiya Grace- Don't like it.
Logan Rose- I think this one is my favorite, gorgeous!
These are the ones I like very much! Finley Marie-Claire Faith-Logan Rose. I also think Finley Rose, Finley Grace and Finley Claire sound wonderful together.
Great taste in names!
Claire and Faith are both lovely names.
Clara Faith would be nice!
personally, I like Claire.
if you want something a bit trendier why not try Claire Logan?
I used to love Finley for a girl, but now I think it's way too popular for boys and I wouldn't want to use a super popular name. Not a fan of Marie in the middle...I think every other girl I went to school with (born mid 80s) had Marie as a middle name.
Don't really love Carleigh, no matter what the spelling. Bronwyn/Bronwen is a name I had never heard before coming on Nameberry...I don't know how I feel about it yet.
Claire is pretty, but like others said, Claire Faith doesn't sound as good as Claire with a 2 or 3 syllable middle name or Clara Faith.
Makiya...I am guessing it's pronounced Ma-key-a? There are so many Makenzie/Makena/Makayla names that I don't think this will stand out. It's very different than your other choices to me. Also think people will struggle with pronounciation.
I know a girl named Logan and I think it suits her. However, it's a VERY common name for little boys. Not sure I would use it for that reason.
So...I would choose Claire Faith, of your options. But I would consider a different middle name or making it Clara Faith!
Finley & Logan - is very common on boys and if your prepared for her to be the only girl with the name Finley or Logan in a class of 5/6 Finley's and Logan's then go for it but I wouldn't.
Claire - to me Claire is a lovely middle name but I wouldn't use it as a first name. If you like it go for it Claire Bronwyn is lovely.
Makiya - it's looks a nice name but the child will be forever spelling her name to people. Michaela or Kayla or Kiya or Kyla would be better. Michaela Grace/Rose/Faith is lovely.
Carleigh - is cute but I don't like the spelling Carley or Carly or Karley (I know someone with this spelling she's a close mate). Carley Bronwyn sounds nice Grace/Rose/Faith/Marie is ok with this name also.
Okay, I will be BRUTAL! ;)
Finley Marie - Bad. Finley is a boy's name and Marie is a filler mn.
Carleigh Bronwyn - Bad. Carleigh is a terribly trendy spelling. Bronwyn is okay. A better combination would be Carly Bronwen.
Claire Faith - Claire is lovely, but doesn't match well with Faith.
Makiya Grace - Bad. Makiya sounds awfully trendy and Grace is a filler mn.
Logan Rose - Bad. Logan is a boy's name and Rose is a filler mn.
Best first name options: Carly, Claire, Grace and Rose.
I think Claire Makiya or Faith Makiya would be lovely together. Plus I think the name is extra special with your Grandma's name in it. :)