Matilda Eloise Bennett
Matilda Penelope Bennett
I prefer Matilda Eloise. I feel like Matilda Penelope is too consonant heavy, if that makes sense. Eloise softens the harsher sounds in Matilda.
We like the flow of Matilda Eloise a lot but really like the name Penelope. If Penelope wasn't getting so popular we would have picked it as our top choice. I see what you mean about all the consonants
I like either one - they are both beautiful combos! But I think Matilda Eloise flows the nicest with your last name.