You have a great list, your little girl will have a lovely name whatever you chose!
Magnolia Rae- pretty name, Magnolia is a favorite of mine... Very unique and classy.
Matilda Rae- cute, I like Matilda but it's not my favorite from your list.
Amelia Rae- a nice name, I prefer other names on your list because of popularity.
Eleanor Rae- my favorite, I love the name Eleanor and Rae makes it fun.
Personally I would go with Eleanor or Magnolia.
Magnolia! Absolutely stunning.
Magnolia is beautiful!
Magnolia Rae is my pick! Magnolia seems to be popular among Berries though.
I don't see the appeal of Matilda. It is frumpy. Tilly and Tilda are cute.
Amelia is nice. It's just too popular for me. Millie is a cute nn, but I think lots of Amelia's go by Millie...
Eleanor is another name that I have never cared for. Ellie is cute, but you can get that nn from other names, like Elizabeth.
No, not Everly. Way too trendy. The other names on your list are classics and much nicer.