Constance cuz I think Connie is okay. I find Ottilie to be too strange sounding and it would have spelling/pronunciation issues.
Caroline - I love Caroline!
Talita, I guess. I love Lita!
Juliet or Isabelle - tough choice! I love them both. I think Juliet since Isabelle is more popular.
Kay or Wendy - neither! negative associations with them both
Rebecca - nn Becca
Charlotte - I love Lottie!
Tilda - I love Tilda, but really dislike Matilda
Louise - Lulu is adorable! I would pick Alison, but it is my niece's name
Irene - nn Renie
Georgia - nn Gigi
Mara or Darcie - not a fan of either
Ela? That is a Greek word. There is a restaurant here named Ela! I think it means Come in, or something like that. Do you mean Ella?
I have never cared for the name Poppy, as it is something people call their grandfather.
Carla or Shauna - these are too dated names that I have never liked
Ottilie or Constance - Otillie
Carolyn or Caroline - Caroline
Justina or Talita - I don't care for either.
Emma or Molly - Molly, though I like both.
Lucy or Anna - Anna
Holly or Tilly - Holly
Juliet or Isabelle - I like both, but Juliet is my favorite.
Kristina or Rhiannon - Rhiannon
Kay or Wendy - I don't care for either
Phoebe or Melanie - Phoebe
Rosie or Gemma - Gemma
Laura or Rebecca - Rebecca
Lauren or Zoe - Zoe
Tierney or Rosanna - Rosanna
Charlotte or Sophia - Sophia
Tilda or Marta - Marta
Francesca or Mariella - Francesca
Victorine or Cecelia - Cecelia
Mary or Harriet - Mary
Louise or Alison - Louise
Irene or Jemima - Jemima
Ashleigh or Georgia - Georgia
Sabrina or Natasha - Natasha
Mara or Darcie - Mara
Rachel or Diana - Rachel
Tabitha or Esther - I like both, but Tabitha has really developed a crush on Tabitha
Anneka or Freya - Freya
Ela or Poppy - Poppy
Amy or Carol - Amy
Carla or Shauna - I don't care for either
Ottilie or Constance- Constance. I hate Ottilie
Carolyn or Caroline- Caroline, but I do like Carolyn too
Justina or Talita- Justina. Talita sounds made up
Emma or Molly- Molly, but I don't really like either
Lucy or Anna- Anna, but I like both
Holly or Tilly- Holly, not a fan of Tilly
Juliet or Isabelle- Juliet- though I like Isabel
Kristina or Rhiannon- Rhiannon, but I do like Kristina
Kay or Wendy- Wendy
Phoebe or Melanie- Melanie
Rosie or Gemma- Gemma, but I like Rose better than Rosie by far and Gemma too
Laura or Rebecca- Rebecca, but no nicknames
Lauren or Zoe- Zoe
Tierney or Rosanna- Rosanna
Charlotte or Sophia- Sophia, but not a fan of either
Tilda or Marta- Marta, but dislike both
Francesca or Mariella- Francesca
Victorine or Cecelia- Victorine
Mary or Harriet- Mary
Louise or Alison- Alison
Irene or Jemima- Irene
Ashleigh or Georgia- Georgia
Sabrina or Natasha- Natasha
Mara or Darcie- Mara
Rachel or Diana- Diana, but I like Rachel too
Tabitha or Esther- Tabitha
Anneka or Freya- Anneka
Ela or Poppy- Ela
Amy or Carol- Amy
Carla or Shauna- Shauna
-Justina (don't really like either though)
-Wendy (though not fond of either)
-Rosanna (although again, don't like either)
-Rachel (this was tough though)
-Freya (but I dont like either)