Anastasia is such a lovely name. Beautiful.
I think I am one of the only berries on this site that just does not see the appeal of Anastasia at all. Despite the hype, I just see it as a mouthful of a name when Ana is just perfect by itself. I do, however, love both Victoria and Elodie. If I had to choose one....I would pick Elodie. As I think it fits in beautifully with your other names.
Anastasia, while a pretty name, seems a bit much when coupled with Genevieve.
Victoria is a classic, but its nicknames (Vicky, Vick, Tori) are all unappealing, IMO.
So my vote goes to Elodie. It's the most uncommon of the three and might garner you some double-takes from people encountering it for the first time, but once you roll it off the tongue a couple times you really fall in love with it.
Vote for Anastasia, I think it fits your other kids' names perfectly.
I adore Anastasia, such a beautiful name!
Thanks. My two oldest kids go by nicknames, but Genevieve does not. So it would work either way. I love Victoria but completely agree about the nicknames. I would cringe if someone called her Vicki! Glad people are liking Elodie -- haven't quite sold my hubby on it, but I also think it works well with our sibset. Of course, she would likely have the nickname Ellie, which is pretty popular.