I think all of your names are gorgeous. My daughter's name is actually Julianna, too!
If I had to pick a name for my daughter's sister from your list, I'd definitely go with Abigail. It's classic and I'm in love with the nickname "Abby". If you call your daughter "Jules" then "Jules and Abby" sounds perfect in my opinion.
Also, go easy on your "picky" (lol) husband. He's going to be greatly outnumbered on many decisions in his life... he deserves a say in this one.
Congratulations! I have 2 girls (Isabella - 4yrs, Leah - 2yrs) and we're currently expecting our 3rd child. We're both hoping for a boy!
How old is your current daughter? That might help determine whether or not they'll ever be considered "twins" based on a name. Because nobody thinks that my daughters are twins... they couldn't look any different... haha.
My DH and I prefer family names, so if any of your names have a family base, I'd lean towards that. But from your list, I'd pick Abigail. And to agree with the last posting, Abby and Jules is beautiful!
Please let me know what you end up going with, because we're running out of girl names... haha.
Josephine is one of our top names but Julianna and her sister will be 13 months apart, and I have a twin sister, so I'm definitely nervous about people thinking they're twins. We also call Jules Julesie sometimes and worry that Julesie and Josie are just too similar.
Abigail is my husbands favorite. And I agree, Jules and Abby are great together. But I just have a hang up against it! I'm not sure what it is.
Unfortunately he won't budge on Rosemary and now he's so in love with Abigail Rosalie seems out.
Olivia and Sofia are too popular (his words).
We like Caroline but don't like any of the nick names.
I love Charlotte but our best friends have been saying for years that if they have a girl it will be Charlotte and she's due a few weeks after me so I could never steal it from them.
So right now we're between Josephine and Abigail (although he doesn't know I'm considering Abby). I'll keep you updated! Thanks for the help!!