the unique baby name guide by the world's leading experts

MIDDLE NAMES: The Strange, The Ordinary, and The Embarrassing

no-timeBestselling novelist JACQUELYN MITCHARD, whose new book No Time To Wave Goodbye, a sequel to her Deep End of the Ocean, will be published this month, meditates on the middle name as payback, placeholder…..and downright embarrassment.

Middle names often are payback – a best friend, a deceased auntie, a family crest. My son Will’s name is William Gordon Pendragon Brent, because of contributions from his brothers and godparents. Many, many people hate their middle names, especially if they’re names such as Miriam, Ursula or Von. Others adore them: Novelist Harper Lee’s real first name was Nelle (pronounced “Nell“), Carson McCullers’ first name was Lula, and, in the modern era, the great Lorrie Moore’s given first name is … well, Marie.

Some people don’t have middle names. My agent does not. Her name is Jane. Plain Jane, while her sister has a first and middle name. My husband doesn’t have a middle name. When he fills out documents, his middle name is “NMI,” or “No Middle Initial.” So the kids say his name is Christopher Nimmie.

Recently, I took a desktop poll. It was based on my old pal Tim Cuprisin’s contention that everyone we grew up with in Chicago had the middle name Marie.

Indeed, Marie was a favorite among our 50s or 60s-born contemporaries. Horsing around between fitful bouts of writing the news, Tim and I gave even our male co-workers the middle name Marie (James Marie, Tommy Marie). Years later, my 13-year-old and I play this same game, asking around to discover the hidden middle Maries. Kazart! Many young girls’ middle names are either Marie or that other ’50s-60s favorite, Ann, even if the person’s first name is Keihley or Phyllis, Maya or Serena.

What is it about Ann or Marie that makes those names such a great afterthought?

bizarro-middle-name-atAs a first name, Ann is stately, aristocratic and given to the adorable nickname “Annie.” Anne Boleyn, Anne Bancroft, Anne Hathaway.

Marie calls to mind the matrons of my youth – strong women who made good food and had permanent waves and could burst into song or a jitterbug at the drop of a fedora.

Interestingly, the first Female Speaker of the House of Representatives, Nancy Pelosi, is middle-named Patricia. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton’s middle name is Diane and former Governor of Alaska and now Mouthpiece Around Town Sarah Palin’s is Louise.

However, Katie Couric, Jessica Simpson, Hilary Swank, Jennifer Garner and punk rock singer Shirley Manson, among many, many, many others, have the middle name “Ann” or “Anne.” First Daughter Malia Obama is Malia Ann even though mom’s is the more exotic Michelle LaVaughn Obama.

Diva Patti LuPone’s middle name is Ann, although her first name is really a last name: Her great-grand-aunt was the celebrated 19th century opera singer Adelina Patti.

Marie seems to require a bit more ethnic specificity. In German and Latin American countries, both men and women often have the middle name “Marie” or “Maria” (among them the famed writer of All Quiet on the Western Front, Erich Maria Remarque), in part because of its sacred Catholic connotation.

Yet, in my desktop poll, conducted among my friends on Facebook, off Facebook and Down Under (which is to say, in cemeteries, not in Australia) the reigning middle name seems to be Ann, and its variations (An – yes, I have seen it – Ayn and Anne) seems to be, still and always the reigning middle name. It’s short, classy and goes with everything.

My own middle name?

It’s Gay. For a while I changed that pretty name to Grace. But now I love it again and use it happily.

For more on Jacquelyn Mitchard’s books and to read her blog, including this one in slightly different form, go to jackiemitchard.com.

Blog Widget by LinkWithin

Tags: , , , , ,

36 Responses to “MIDDLE NAMES: The Strange, The Ordinary, and The Embarrassing”
rachelmarie Says:

September 3rd, 2009 at 12:25 am

My middle name is Marie, as seen from my username.
It’s really popular of the people I know. My best friend’s middle name is Marie, and so is her mom’s middle name. I know about 15 girls with the middle name Marie. I know about 9 with the middle name Anne.

Many people consider Marie to be a filler middle name. While I agree it does go well with just about anything, it does have meaning for some people. For example, I was given the middle name Marie because it was the name of my mother’s favorite grandmother.

Jill Says:

September 3rd, 2009 at 12:38 am

Jacquelyn Mitchard? Seriously? Wow! :-) “Deep End of the Ocean” is one of my favorite books (I loved the movie, too), and I had absolutely no idea that a sequel was coming out! (Memo to self: Must. Buy. Book.)

I, too, love Anne as a first name (with the “e”), but like you said, it’s overused as a middle name. The same goes for Rose: #1 in the world of middle names, but underused and charmingly elegant (at least to me) as a first name.

Thanks for the blog, and best wishes on your book!

Grace Conway Says:

September 3rd, 2009 at 12:46 am

The most popular middle names at my high school are by far are Marie, Ann(e) and Rose. I do consider both Marie and Rose to be filler middle names because they sound good with almost all first names and are rarely used in the first name position.

For my entire life (15 years) I have absolutely hated my middle name. My parents decided to honor my Japanese great grandmother who died during my mother’s pregnancy. I do like that I was named after a family member, but I wish it was just less weird :( My middle name is Kofuki, pronounced Koff-kee. It does not even register as an actual name on this website and most others.

Lauren Says:

September 3rd, 2009 at 12:54 am

Thanks for the blog! I completely agree about “go to” middle names. I have always felt the same way about Ann, Marie, Rose, Michelle and especially Nicole. During high school, I cannot even tell you the number of girls whose mn was Nicole. I knew 2 or 3 Ashley Nicole’s–all unrelated with the same last name, as well!

lyndsayjenness Says:

September 3rd, 2009 at 1:26 am

When I was little, I had five girl friends on my block. Christina Marie and Angela Michelle were sisters, Cameron Marie and Taylor Ann were sisters, and Natalie Marie. I was so jealous that my middle name wasn’t Marie, and I gave my dog Annalee and my cat Flower that as a middle name. My mom is Katherine Ann, and my grandma is Ann Rose, so there is a good chance I may use Ann some day.

Oh, I have two sister-in-laws (not sisters themselves): Shannon Marie and Julie Marie. I am destined to be surrounded by great women with the middle name Marie, feeling left out. Not really though, I completely love my middle name and wouldn’t change if for the world. It’s Jenness, the surname of my ancestors who immigrated here from France long ago. It’s been in use as a middle in my family for several generations.

teabee Says:

September 3rd, 2009 at 2:26 am

I can’t think of anyone in my family with a common middle name off the top of my head; I need to double-check the middles of a couple relatives…

Barbara Says:

September 3rd, 2009 at 2:39 am

Ah, middle names. We have a mix of the afterthoughts (Ann, May, Marie) and more unique ones (Lenore, Elise). I don’t think there’s a family system for girls. (For the boys, it’s fairly strict–one line all has the same first name, and they choose from a total of two middle names with the same initial. They’re on the sixth generation of this, though the current baby is going by his middle name.)

susan Says:

September 3rd, 2009 at 3:49 am

We don’t have anybody with the middle name Marie in our family. Most women have the middle name Elizabeth. Mine was Sue, but I didn’t like Sue. So I lengthened it to Susan and made it my first name. I didn’t get the middle name Elizabeth because my sister already had it. My middle name would have probably been Ann, but my cousin’s first name was Ann. We were a very close family. I was pretty happy with Sue compared to other middle names I might have gotten such as Velma, my great grandmother’s name.
One of my best friends is Lissa Marie. Her mother was named Marie. My best friend from Colorado was Laura Marie and her daughter was Hailey Marie. Years ago I knew a young man named Steve who named his cat Candace Marie. She was very pretty.

redriding Says:

September 3rd, 2009 at 6:01 am

I only know one woman with Marie as a middle name – Janette Marie, born in 1966. (I remember it well, a hot August day, I was 13 and England won the World Cup at football, but as usual I am rambling).

I LOATHE my middle name, (Joyce) as all Nameberries will know, but it is my 88 year old Mum’s name, so it causes her hurt to keep telling her that.

Over here, ROSE is very popular as a middle name, while it used to be Lynne or Anne.

Very interesting blog!

Anna Says:

September 3rd, 2009 at 6:01 am

mine is Michelle, My sisters Loren and the other Nicole. My brothers Allan Weeber (dad’s and my mum’s maiden) and the other Scott. My hubby’s is James.

beccalynn Says:

September 3rd, 2009 at 7:43 am

I was named Rebecca Lynn for the sole reason that it “sounded good together” and was “easy to spell” – so that’s my default definition for a filler middle name. My sister’s mn is Faye, which she’s always hated, but I’ve come to envy the charm and personality of it.

It’s interesting in the “grass is greener” sense, because my sister plans to give her children more common middle names, while my own daughter will receive a fairly unique one when she arrives in November.

Sylvia Says:

September 3rd, 2009 at 7:55 am

Okay, Pendragon is a sweet middle name.

And Gay is a beautiful name that I mourn the passing of…

phaedra Says:

September 3rd, 2009 at 8:08 am

My pet theory is that we favor French-derived middle names such as Marie, Michelle, Nicole, and Renee, because of the emphasis on the last syllable. That makes these names really flow well with a wide variety of first and last names.

I was so intrigued by this phenomenon that I started a thread about multisyllabic middle names … maybe it’s still in the forums somewhere?

My own middle, however, is not French- it’s Susan, after my aunt. :)

Andrea Says:

September 3rd, 2009 at 8:15 am

A few years ago, when I was keeping track of birth announcements in the state, Ann, Marie, and Lee were still the most popular middle names for girls. They were by far the most popular middle names in my graduating class for girls as well. Those who didn’t have Ann, Marie or Lee were usually Lynn/Lynne/Lyn or Dee, May/Mae, or Kay/Kae or Renee/Renae or Beth. My middle name is Kay; my female cousins have the middle names Ruth (after our grandmother), Ann, Anne, Renae, and Devon (I think she was a character on some soap opera at the time and inspired my aunt). One has my aunt’s maiden name as a middle name. The male cousins had the male equivalents as middle names: Ray, Lee, Lynn or their father’s first names as their middles. When I cover graduation ceremonies for colleges or high schools or preschools, you see those same middle names repeated over and over, sometimes combined — AnnMarie, JoLynn, Raeleigh, LeeAnn, MaeLynn, etc., now with the addition of Rose or Grace for very little girls. The short, one-syllable, rhyming middle names seem to be pretty typical in the Midwestern United States. I remember comparing middle names with classmates and enjoying having the same middle names in common. The one or two girls who had longer middle names stuck out.

Andrea Says:

September 3rd, 2009 at 8:19 am

I regard my confirmation name as a second middle name. One of the girls in my confirmation class selected her saint’s name so it would sound good with her middle name, Marie and asked the priest if the confirmation name could be placed ahead of her given middle name on the confirmation certificate. Her name was Monique Marie and she then became Monique Anne Marie. My confirmation name is Elizabeth, picked mainly because it is also my mother’s middle name and I disliked her first name, Margaret, when I was 13. I wonder how many Catholic kids enjoy being confirmed because they get to pick another middle name?

Em Says:

September 3rd, 2009 at 8:44 am

I think phaedra has it right as to why these are popular- it’s the rhythm of them that makes them so popular.

My middle name is the same as my mom’s (Jean) and I plan to use it as a middle name if I have a daughter as well. For our son, we used my husband’s name (Michael) as his middle name. For first names, we pick names we like that aren’t in the immediate family, and then use a family name for the middle name. We like our child having his “own” name, as opposed to sharing it with a grandparent etc. but then we can honor family in the middle name.

I don’t understand why people just pick a “it just sounds good” name, that seems like a waste of an opportunity to pick a name to me!
I’m not saying it’s a bad thing for people to choose their names differently, that’s just our philosophy!

Abby Says:

September 3rd, 2009 at 8:53 am

I recently discovered that a friend of mine has the middle name Rhunette.

The interesting thing is that many middle names that start out as filler – Anne, Marie, etc. – seem to be passed down as family names. Wasn’t it Jessica Alba who named her daughter Honor Marie because Marie is her middle name? That always strikes me as curious.

But then, I love Pendragon.

Pam Says:

September 3rd, 2009 at 9:00 am

Hmmm, interesting, Abby. Makes me think of your guest post on the secret meaning of names and how that might morph over time, so that a filler middle name like Ann or Marie chosen because it was bland as a hyphen might over time acquire a different more important meaning: A family name worth passing down through the generations.

robynkit Says:

September 3rd, 2009 at 9:33 am

The way I see it is Ann, Marie or Lyn are so common as middle names that you may as well not bestow those on your child if you are just using them as fillers. It’s perfectly alright not to have a middle name or just to have an initial.

My father in law has the initial “R”. My mom and dad both have no middle names and none of us have common middle names. Try Kitrina, Roxanne, or Dare on for size! It’s best to choose a wonderful, distinctive middle name for your child.

Pam Says:

September 3rd, 2009 at 9:41 am

OK, but can somebody please explain the initial as middle name phenomenon to me?? Talk about a placeholder!

diana Says:

September 3rd, 2009 at 9:47 am

As a joke, I have always called my cats their names, plus Marie when I get mad at them. Hermione Marie! Abby Marie! I guess that’s how over-used the name is.

Definitely over-used and definitely dates someone. I’m so glad that nowadays people have more choices. I think you can name your kids just about anything now…..depending on the part of the country you live in….and get away with it. A lot of the names people use now, you wouldn’t have dared used them when I was younger. I don’t think that it was so much that our parents lacked imagination. I think it was that they knew the horrible fate that would be in store for their children if they crossed that boundary. Especially here in the mid west, where we are not known for our naming originality.

ADC Says:

September 3rd, 2009 at 10:24 am

I have always loved my middle name (Dawn), mainly because it is my mom’s first name. When I was a kid I always thought that she must have really liked me to name me after herself. I plan on passing it to my daughter. Plus, I love the sound of a one syllable middle name with a longer first and last name, but I wouldn’t want the middle name to be “just a filler.”

ADC Says:

September 3rd, 2009 at 10:26 am

Also, working with children, I get to see tons of names, and I have to say, Grace is BY FAR the most popular middle name in my area.

Millikate Says:

September 3rd, 2009 at 10:28 am

All my friends from back in high school had a group of the same middle names. It was either Lynn, Anne, Nicole, or Elizabeth except for one Monique, who she absolutely hated her middle name. :)

http://names4real.wordpress.com/

msmoll Says:

September 3rd, 2009 at 11:03 am

My fellow Gen Xers all seem to have Lyn as a middle name. Both my mother and my mother-in-law have Ann. I agree these classic and simple names can be great fillers, but I think people miss out on the opportunity to use the middle name as a tribute, or to use a name they love but wouldn’t necessarily use as a first name. My dad’s middle name is Downell, after his father’s friend who was shot down the day my dad was born. It honored a friend, and gave my dad a connection to someone important. I say with so many great names and people out there, why pick a filler?

lyndsay jenness Says:

September 3rd, 2009 at 11:06 am

ADC- “I always though she must really like me to name me after herself.” That is so cute! I never thought about it that way before, makes me want to name a baby after myself.

Kerri Says:

September 3rd, 2009 at 1:42 pm

I am the 8th (or 9th) Julia in a line on my mother’s side. Its my middle name, but can be first or middle. Sadly I have 2 sons (and no more are coming) so the tradition ends with me I guess. Maybe they will have daughters and pick it up again…. the name also comes with a spinning wheel! My mom STILL doesn’t have the spinning wheel, I’ll probably be 70 by the time I get it.

ScarlettsMom Says:

September 3rd, 2009 at 2:19 pm

My best friend’s mn is Marie. In my family, two of us have “common” mns (but they were actually named for family members) and two of us don’t. I think all of our names flow well and match in style though – Amanda Jane, Megan Lori, Rachel Michelle, and Ashley Lynn.

Kathleen Says:

September 3rd, 2009 at 2:46 pm

My middle name is also Marie! After my mom, Mary. I considered it for my own daughter as a ‘family name’. so I agree with the PP!!

stephanie_elizabeth Says:

September 4th, 2009 at 11:23 am

My middle name, as you can ese, is Elizabeth, but a LOT of the girls i graduated with had Marie as a middle name. So much so that I used to call my friends _____ Marie (Amanda Marie, Alicia Marie, Kayla Marie) as a joke. Only two of my friends had “unusual” middle names, and they were June (after her mom, Jane, I think) and Laurel.

People are

stephanie_elizabeth Says:

September 4th, 2009 at 11:27 am

getting more creative about middle names though. My best friend named her two daughters Natalie Eowyn and Aspen Phoenix. My cousins did prettygood, as well. I have little ones named Hunter Ray, Creighton Jason Dean, Jude Adam, Millie Claire, and Brooklynn MacKenzie.

(sorry, this is a contination of my earlier post. I accidently hit submit before I was done typing.)

Ann(TobysMommy) Says:

September 6th, 2009 at 12:58 am

My mother’s middle name is Ann, and my father’s mother’s name is Anne. As a result, my first name is Ann. I have lost count of the number of times I have I heard “Oh! That’s my sister’s/cousin’s/aunt’s/mother’s/dog’s middle name!” I’ve always resented Ann for being so plain and boring. Oddly enough, I could never stand being called Annie, so I was always just Ann. I would have liked to be Anna, but it never caught on. People insisted that I just “was an Ann”

Stacy Says:

September 8th, 2009 at 6:36 am

My middle name is Claire, but my mom’s middle name is Ann. It’s definitely common. Meanwhile, my mother–in-law’s middle name was Lynn, although she actually legally changed her name to reverse first and middle names since she goes by Lynn anyway.

I do have to agree that it seems like Grace is the current used-everywhere middle name for girls. I know so many babies with that middle name!

Catherine Says:

September 19th, 2009 at 8:23 am

My middle name is Elizabeth, after my mom (who goes by Betty) and when it came time to name my daughter, I gave her a name that was “hers” and had no family connotations for a first name and Elizabeth for a middle name after me and my mom (coincidentally I see another Stephanie Elizabeth posting in this thread – too funny!)

Karen Says:

September 20th, 2009 at 6:13 pm

You know what, I think there is a lot of emphasis on “how it will sound”, the flow, I guess we call it. I don’t really think my name flows. It’s ok, I guess, but since I just about never hear it all together, it has its own lyrical sound when it is spoken. People don’t seem to favor short first names, especially monosyllabic ones, but the short names and 2-syllable names with the emphasis on the second syllable get that “flow”. It’s kind of garanimals for naming your child. I do like names like Claire and Rose and Marie for first names lately, not so much Ann or Lynn. I definitely favor a variety of rhythms when hearing people’s names instead of a formula. My sister and brother both have 2-2-2 names that sound not at all predictable, no need to mix it up or inject assymetry. My middle name has 3 syllables. Since it never really comes up, it doesn’t really matter if they hit some sort of favorable rhythm, but with a multi-syllabic first name and who knows what for a last name, the short middle name almost always sounds “just right.”

When I am looking at suggestions discouraging certain combinations for sounds that run together or two similar in rhythm, I think we are complying with some ideal that a full name hits a certain lyrical, asymmetrical rhythm, and parents who are going for it without any type of research (to books or sites like this) or willingness or interest in churning up an extra set of decisions, are probably going by that habit.

Another thought that just comes to mind is that people (the ones who aren’t obsessed in life about names) tend to have their list of favorite names to choose from for a first name – unless something comes to them that means something, I may hazard to guess that aside from using their own predictable middle name that’s passed down the line, people may tend not to look for their second favorite name off the list they just whittled down for a middle name. They might want to use it in the future and pick a more ordinary name for the middle that’s sort of ok and inoffensive, does the job, is not totally heinous or embarrassing to their child. I prefer something really interesting or meaningful or daring in that spot, but just the same, it almost never comes up, so I can see why people choose not to bother.

HAPPY BIRTHDAY TO NAMEBERRY! – Baby Name Blog - Nameberry Says:

October 11th, 2009 at 7:24 pm

[...] including the man who started the Social Security list Michael Shackleford and bestselling novelist Jacquelyn Mitchard, along with many parents who’ve shared the stories of naming their own [...]

Leave a Reply

Search
Categories